Human Biology : Concepts and Current Issues - With Access
Human Biology : Concepts and Current Issues - With Access
7th Edition
ISBN: 9780321874856
Author: Johnson
Publisher: PEARSON
bartleby

Concept explainers

bartleby

Videos

Textbook Question
Chapter 22, Problem 1QC

Do you think the skeletons of Liang Bua Cave should be called a new species? Does it matter?

Expert Solution & Answer
Check Mark
Summary Introduction

To review:

The consideration one would make while placing the skeleton from the Liang Bua cave in a different species and the reason for the necessity of the distinction.

Introduction:

Skeletons of fourteen prehistoric hominids were discovered in a cave called Liang Bua in 2004, named LB 1 to 14. These skeletons resemble the genus Australopithecus but also has similarities to the Homo species. They were classified as new species and named Homo floresiensis. However, some scientists argue that these specimens do not represent new species and are related to Homo sapiens.

Explanation of Solution

The prominent argument against accepting LB1 as another species was that the brain size was smaller than the modern humans. In case, they were different species evolved from H. erectus, their brain size should not have been affected. However, there are other factors to be considered. The factors that help in defining LB1 as different species are as follows:

1. Facial characteristics like heavy brow ridges, sloping forehead, and small chin are distinctive. The shape of the LB1 wrist resembled H. habilis (homo), which was necessary for absorbing the impact of shock and provide stability while using heavy tools. H. habilis is extinct for 1.6 million years.

2. The toes are short and in line like humans. The foot lacks arch is longer in proportion to the human foot. So their gait was high-stepping and running was poor. So, it is estimated that the LB1 evolved from H. erectus and diverged from the line of evolution that gave rise to modern humans.

3. LB1 skeletons were found in a cave with other skeletons of same characteristics, some tools, and skeleton of Stegodon, a small relative of modern elephants. This means the LBs could use tools, hunt and had coordination abilities that facilitate a hunt and interaction within the group. Their brain size may be small, but they could accomplish such tasks.

When all this information is taken into account, it can be safely estimated that LB1 represents a different species. Differentiating LB1 as a different species is very important. Some of the arguments to support the necessity of this distinction are as follows:

1. Naming LB1 as a different species showed that just the brain size is not an indicator of the difference in species. The coordination of different LB individual has overcome challenges from reduced brain size.

2. Naming LB1 as a different species paved a way for taking entire characteristics of the specimen before differentiating it into one species or another.

3. Evidence suggests the species had a larger brain before migrating to the island. So it will be worth finding whether the brain size was reduced as an evolutionary measure. The differentiation established an offshoot of H. erectus survived for a long period and may have interacted with the H. sapiens.

Conclusion

Therefore, based on all the information available on the LB1 skeleton, they do represent a different species. This distinction is necessary as it proved brain size is not the only indicator in the differentiating between different species.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!
Students have asked these similar questions
How do the Miocene fossil primates differ from the Oligocene fossil primates? Thank you so much!!
Can you ID ancestral skulls and non-human primate skulls? At least, which is older?
Which hominins might be ancestral to us?

Chapter 22 Solutions

Human Biology : Concepts and Current Issues - With Access

Knowledge Booster
Biology
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, biology and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
    • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
    Recommended textbooks for you
  • Human Anatomy & Physiology (11th Edition)
    Biology
    ISBN:9780134580999
    Author:Elaine N. Marieb, Katja N. Hoehn
    Publisher:PEARSON
    Biology 2e
    Biology
    ISBN:9781947172517
    Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann Clark
    Publisher:OpenStax
    Anatomy & Physiology
    Biology
    ISBN:9781259398629
    Author:McKinley, Michael P., O'loughlin, Valerie Dean, Bidle, Theresa Stouter
    Publisher:Mcgraw Hill Education,
  • Molecular Biology of the Cell (Sixth Edition)
    Biology
    ISBN:9780815344322
    Author:Bruce Alberts, Alexander D. Johnson, Julian Lewis, David Morgan, Martin Raff, Keith Roberts, Peter Walter
    Publisher:W. W. Norton & Company
    Laboratory Manual For Human Anatomy & Physiology
    Biology
    ISBN:9781260159363
    Author:Martin, Terry R., Prentice-craver, Cynthia
    Publisher:McGraw-Hill Publishing Co.
    Inquiry Into Life (16th Edition)
    Biology
    ISBN:9781260231700
    Author:Sylvia S. Mader, Michael Windelspecht
    Publisher:McGraw Hill Education
  • Human Anatomy & Physiology (11th Edition)
    Biology
    ISBN:9780134580999
    Author:Elaine N. Marieb, Katja N. Hoehn
    Publisher:PEARSON
    Biology 2e
    Biology
    ISBN:9781947172517
    Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann Clark
    Publisher:OpenStax
    Anatomy & Physiology
    Biology
    ISBN:9781259398629
    Author:McKinley, Michael P., O'loughlin, Valerie Dean, Bidle, Theresa Stouter
    Publisher:Mcgraw Hill Education,
    Molecular Biology of the Cell (Sixth Edition)
    Biology
    ISBN:9780815344322
    Author:Bruce Alberts, Alexander D. Johnson, Julian Lewis, David Morgan, Martin Raff, Keith Roberts, Peter Walter
    Publisher:W. W. Norton & Company
    Laboratory Manual For Human Anatomy & Physiology
    Biology
    ISBN:9781260159363
    Author:Martin, Terry R., Prentice-craver, Cynthia
    Publisher:McGraw-Hill Publishing Co.
    Inquiry Into Life (16th Edition)
    Biology
    ISBN:9781260231700
    Author:Sylvia S. Mader, Michael Windelspecht
    Publisher:McGraw Hill Education
    Fossil: The Language & History of Paleontology; Author: Alliterative;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9yNwRBlKtU;License: Standard youtube license