Essentials of Genetics
Essentials of Genetics
9th Edition
ISBN: 9781292108933
Author: KLUG
Publisher: PEARSON
bartleby

Concept explainers

bartleby

Videos

Textbook Question
Chapter 6, Problem 1CS

CASE STUDY| Fish tales

Aquatic vegetation overgrowth, usually controlled by dredging or herbicides, represents a significant issue in maintaining private and public waterways. In 1963, diploid grass carp were introduced in Arkansas to consume vegetation, but they reproduced prodigiously and spread to eventually become a hazard to aquatic ecosystems in 35 states. In the 1980s, many states adopted triploid grass carp as an alternative because of their high, but not absolute, sterility and their longevity of seven to ten years. Today, most states require permits for vegetation control by triploid carp, requiring their containment in the body of water to which they are introduced. Genetic modifications of organisms to achieve specific outcomes willcertainly become more common in the future and raise several interesting questions.

Taking triploid carp as an example, what controversies may emerge as similar modified species become available for widespread use?

Expert Solution & Answer
Check Mark
Summary Introduction

To review:

The controversies that emerge from using modified species available for widespread use, keeping in mind the case of triploid grass carp.

Introduction:

There exist aquatic weeds which is harmful to the survival of other species. Grass carp are genetically modified so that it could wipe away the population of these weeds. These genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are made to be survived for a longer time, for about a period of five to ten years.

Explanation of Solution

Grass carp is a genetically modified fish which is used for controlling aquatic weed but there are also few controversies associated with their use-

1) Incorrect insertion of the gene of interest- During the insertion of the gene of interest, there might occur some undesirable changes in the functionality of organism as while creating triploid grass carp, they may harm aquatic vegetation without disrupting the weed population.

2) Harmful to the environment- Due to gene insertion, the modified organism may start producing toxic substances and releasing it in the environment, affecting the environment negatively. For example- some portion of weed eaten by modified grass carp may not be completely digested and excreted to further cause algal blooms.

3) Resistance by pests and weeds towards the GMOs:A prolonged use of genetically modified organisms against insects, pests or weeds, may cause the development of resistance in these organisms against the GMOs. Hence, the GMOs should be used carefully against other organisms.

4) Disruption to biodiversity and vegetation: If a wide population of a particular species is wiped out then this would disrupt the biodiversity and vegetation of that place. For example- if triploid grass carp starts eating the useful aquatic vegetation along with the weeds then this will pose a harmful impact on the aquatic environment.

5) Harmful to human health- In some cases, GMOs have shown to leave behind toxic substances which cannot be degraded when such substances contaminate a region then it may be later consumed by humans which would result in serious health problems.

Conclusion

Thus, it can be concluded that GMOs are effective and necessary to be used in the modern world but it also has certain drawbacks.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!
Students have asked these similar questions
Progeny of triploid tomato plants often contain parts of an extra chromosome, in addition to the normal complement of 24 chromosomes . Mutantswith a part of an extra chromosome are referred to as secondaries. James and Margaret Lesley observed that secondaries arise from triploid (3 n), trisomic (3 n + 1), and double trisomic (3 n + 1 + 1) parents, but never from diploids (2 n). Give one or more possible reasons that secondaries arise from parents that have unpaired chromosomes but not from parents that are normal diploids.
211 Inheritance 2. The pedigree chart below illustrates the inheritance of a trait (darker symbols) in two families joined in marriage. 2 4 6 8. 10 11 12 13 14 II 4 5 (a) State whether the trait is dominant or recessive, providing a reason for your choice: (b) State whether the trait is sex-linked or not, providing a reason for your choice: 3. The recessive sex-linked gene (h) prolongs the blood-clotting time, resulting in the genetically inherited disease called hemophilia. From the information in the pedigree chart (right), answer the following questions: Hemophilia in humans (a) If 112 marries a normal man, what is the probability of her first child being a hemophiliac? 1 (b) Suppose her first child is actually a hemophiliac. What is the chance that her second child will be a boy with hemophilia? 4 (c) If 114 has children with a hemophiliac man, what is the probability that her first child will be phenotypically normal? (d) If the mother of 12 was phenotypically normal, what…
F2 plants segregate colored : colorless. If acolored plant is picked at random and selfed, what is theprobability that both colored and colorless plants will beseen among a large number of its progeny?   Please solve with step by step please

Chapter 6 Solutions

Essentials of Genetics

Knowledge Booster
Biology
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, biology and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • Controlling the overgrowth of invasive aquatic vegetation is asignificant problem in the waterways of most U.S. states.Originally, herbicides and dredging were used for control, butin 1963, diploid Asian carp were introduced in Alabama and Arkansas.Unfortunately, through escapes and illegal introductions, the carpspread rapidly and became serious threats to aquatic ecosystems in45 states. Beginning in 1983, many states began using triploid, sterilegrass carp as an alternative, because of their inability to reproduce,their longevity, and their voracious appetite. On the other hand, thisgenetically modified exotic species, if not used properly, can reduceor eliminate desirable plants and outcompete native fish, causing moredamage than good. The use of one exotic species to control otherexotic species has had a problematic history across the globe, generatingcontroversy and criticism. Newer methods for genetic modificationof organisms to achieve specific outcomes will certainly becomemore…
    Controlling the overgrowth of invasive aquatic vegetation is asignificant problem in the waterways of most U.S. states.Originally, herbicides and dredging were used for control, butin 1963, diploid Asian carp were introduced in Alabama and Arkansas.Unfortunately, through escapes and illegal introductions, the carpspread rapidly and became serious threats to aquatic ecosystems in45 states. Beginning in 1983, many states began using triploid, sterilegrass carp as an alternative, because of their inability to reproduce,their longevity, and their voracious appetite. On the other hand, thisgenetically modified exotic species, if not used properly, can reduceor eliminate desirable plants and outcompete native fish, causing moredamage than good. The use of one exotic species to control otherexotic species has had a problematic history across the globe, generatingcontroversy and criticism. Newer methods for genetic modificationof organisms to achieve specific outcomes will certainly becomemore…
    Background Info Rainbow trout go through a unique genetic reproductive process. Female eggs are diploid, while male sperm are haploid. In the wild, when the sperm fertilizes an egg, the extra set of chromosomes is kicked out, resulting in a diploid offspring.Triploid trout are produced in the lab to provide sterile fish stock for lakes. Shortly after the eggs are fertilized, scientists place them in a warm water bath to prevent the extra chromosomes from being removed. The result is a triploid fish that cannot reproduce.Rainbow Trout: n = 30 Global warming is an issue affecting many species around the world. Warming has caused the temperatures in lakes and rivers to increase and stay elevated for longer periods of time. Question Select the FOUR numbers that describe the possible effects of global warming on the reproduction of rainbow trout in the wild and on biodiversity. The extra set of chromosomes remains. The extra set of chromosomes is removed. The offspring are diploid (2n).…
    • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
    Recommended textbooks for you
  • Biology: The Dynamic Science (MindTap Course List)
    Biology
    ISBN:9781305389892
    Author:Peter J. Russell, Paul E. Hertz, Beverly McMillan
    Publisher:Cengage Learning
    Biology: The Unity and Diversity of Life (MindTap...
    Biology
    ISBN:9781305073951
    Author:Cecie Starr, Ralph Taggart, Christine Evers, Lisa Starr
    Publisher:Cengage Learning
    Biology 2e
    Biology
    ISBN:9781947172517
    Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann Clark
    Publisher:OpenStax
  • Biology: The Dynamic Science (MindTap Course List)
    Biology
    ISBN:9781305389892
    Author:Peter J. Russell, Paul E. Hertz, Beverly McMillan
    Publisher:Cengage Learning
    Biology: The Unity and Diversity of Life (MindTap...
    Biology
    ISBN:9781305073951
    Author:Cecie Starr, Ralph Taggart, Christine Evers, Lisa Starr
    Publisher:Cengage Learning
    Biology 2e
    Biology
    ISBN:9781947172517
    Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann Clark
    Publisher:OpenStax
    How to solve genetics probability problems; Author: Shomu's Biology;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0yjfb1ooUs;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
    Beyond Mendelian Genetics: Complex Patterns of Inheritance; Author: Professor Dave Explains;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EmvmBuK-B8;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY