Ethics and Sales Returns
At the end of 2019, the accounting firm for which you work is auditing the books of Debitus Publishing Inc. for the first time. Debitus, a calendar year company, publishes textbooks that are used in colleges and universities across the country. These textbooks are purchased by students through their campus bookstores. Debitus normally makes its biggest sales at the beginning of the fall semester. In the past, Debitus has always recorded sales returns in the spring semester when the campus bookstores return any unsold textbooks. This has been satisfactory because the returns have been immaterial in amount.
In 2018, as a promotional strategy to stimulate sales, Debitus began offering bookstores a reduced price if they ordered more textbooks. There is no penalty for returns of these textbooks if the bookstores cannot sell them to customers. This strategy worked; sales increased by 10% during 2018. In early 2019, however, a substantial amount of unsold textbooks were returned by bookstores to Debitus. Continuing the promotional strategy, sales increased by 15% during 2019.
While reviewing the sales returns account for 2019, you notice that the only entry was for the textbooks returned earlier in the year. You note that these returns amounted to about 5% of the sales for the fall semester of 2018. Because this pattern of returns seems to you to be a trend that will continue, you raise the issue with the company controller as to whether all of the “sales” for the fall semester of 2019 are actually revenue. The controller responds, “Of course tiiey are revenue; we sold the textbooks. Just because there will some returns doesn’t mean we haven’t made sales. Besides, we don’t know what percentage the returns will be. They might be as much as 5%, but definitely not more. Furthermore, we have already recorded all those returns at the beginning of 2019 that really applied to 2018. So we already have recorded our fair share of returns for 2019. As long as we record returns consistently, it will all work out. We don’t want a drop in earnings for 2019 because of a change in customer returns, our shareholders wouldn’t like that. Let’s just leave this issue alone.”
Required:
From financial reporting and ethical perspectives, what do you think about Debitus’s policy in regard to sales returns?
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 6 Solutions
Intermediate Accounting: Reporting And Analysis
- On December 1, 2019, AwakcAllNight Inc. sells 5,000 super caffeinated candy bars to Campus Grocers. The candy bars sell for 3 per bar. In addition, AwakcAllNight pays Campus Grocers a 900placement fee to ensure that its candy bars are always stocked prominently by the cash register. The 900 is paid at the end of each month based on the results of random inspections of Campus Grocers by AwakcAllNight to ensure that the terms of the contract are being followed. Required: 1. Determine the transaction price for Awake AllNights revenue contract. 2. Prepare AwakeAllNights journal entries to recognize sales revenue and pay Campus Grocers the placement fee.arrow_forwardSEPTEMBER 2019: In September 2019, Kate incorporated Kate’s Cards after investigating different organizational forms, and began the process of getting her business up and running. The following events occurred during the month of September 2019: Kate deposited $10,000 that she had saved into a newly opened business checking account. She received common stock in exchange. Kate designed a brochure that she will use to promote her greeting cards at local stationery stores. Kate paid Fred Simmons $50 to critique her brochure before undertaking her final design and printing. Kate purchased a new iMac computer tablet, specialized graphic arts software, and commercial printer for the company, paying $4,800 in cash. She decided to record all of these items under the same equipment account. Kate purchased supplies such as paper and ink for $350 at the local stationery store. She opened a business account with the store and was granted 30 days credit on all purchases, including the one she just…arrow_forwardSEPTEMBER 2019: In September 2019, Kate incorporated Kate’s Cards after investigating different organizational forms, and began the process of getting her business up and running. The following events occurred during the month of September 2019: Kate deposited $10,000 that she had saved into a newly opened business checking account. She received common stock in exchange. Kate designed a brochure that she will use to promote her greeting cards at local stationery stores. Kate paid Fred Simmons $50 to critique her brochure before undertaking her final design and printing. Kate purchased a new iMac computer tablet, specialized graphic arts software, and commercial printer for the company, paying $4,800 in cash. She decided to record all of these items under the same equipment account. Kate purchased supplies such as paper and ink for $350 at the local stationery store. She opened a business account with the store and was granted 30 days credit on all purchases, including the one she just…arrow_forward
- In November 2019, Yammy Fun Inc. purchased advertising for $1,000 that ran in the local November newspaper. All purchases and services are made on credit. The bookkeeper, PatrickFitz, recorded the advertising by crediting Supplies Inventory (asset) and debiting accounts payable. In 2020 (the following year), the new bookkeeper, Tua, saw this entry and asked you to help him analyze the entry. What is the correcting entry for 2020? Debit Supplies Inventory and credit Advertising Expense for 1,000.Debit Supplies Inventory and credit Retained Earnings for 1,000Debit Retained Earnings for 1,000 and credit Accounts Payable for 1,000.Debit Advertising Expense for 1,000, debit Supplies Inventory for 1,000, and credit Accounts Payable for2,000Debit Retained Earnings for 1,000, debit Supplies Inventory for 1,000, and credit Accounts Payable for2,000arrow_forwardb) You work in a reputable audit firm and you are currently reviewing the working papers of several audit assignments recently curried out by your audit firm. Each of the audit engagement is nearing completion, but certain matters have recently come to light which may affect your audit opinion on each of the assignments. In each case, the year-end of the company is 30 August 2019.i. Mimie Company (Profit before tax Ghc 750,000)On 6 September 2019 a letter was received informing the company that a customer, who owed the company Ghc 150,000 as at the year-end had been declared bankrupt on 30 August. At the time of the audit it was expected that unsecured creditors, such as Mimie, would receive nothing in respect of this dept. The directors refuse to change the financial statements to provide for the loss, on the grounds that the notification was received by the statement of financial position date.Total debts shown in the statement of financial position amounted to Ghc 2,375,000. ii.…arrow_forwardAccounting & Finance - Auditing Question: You are an audit senior of OLA & Co, planning the final audit of a new client, EAHO Construction Co, for the year ending 30 September 2019. The company specialises in property construction and providing ongoing annual maintenance services for properties previously constructed. Forecast profit before tax is £12m. The audit manager has met with EAHO Co’s finance director and has provided you with the following notes. In line with industry practice, EAHO Co offers its customers a five-year building warranty, which covers any construction defects. Customers are not required to pay any additional fees to obtain the warranty. The finance director anticipates this provision will be lower than last year as the company has improved its building practices and therefore the quality of the finished properties. A full year-end inventory count will be undertaken on 30 September and there is no enough audit team resource to attend all inventory…arrow_forward
- SEPTEMBER 2019: In September 2019, Kate incorporated Kate’s Cards after investigating different organizational forms and began the process of getting her business up and running. The following events occurred during the month of September 2019: Kate deposited $10,000 that she had saved into a newly opened business checking account. She received common stock in exchange. Kate designed a brochure that she will use to promote her greeting cards at local stationery stores. Kate paid Fred Simmons $50 to critique her brochure before undertaking her final design and printing. Kate purchased a new iMac computer tablet, specialized graphic arts software, and commercial printer for the company, paying $4,800 in cash. She decided to record all of these items under the same equipment account. Kate purchased supplies such as paper and ink for $350 at the local stationery store. She opened a business account with the store and was granted 30 days credit on all purchases, including the one she just…arrow_forwardReview the following transactions and prepare any necessary journal entries for Woodworking Magazine. Woodworking Magazine provides one issue per month to subscribers for a service fee of $240 per year. Assume January 1 is the first day of operations for this company, and no new customers join during the year. A. On January 1, Woodworking Magazine receives advance cash payment from forty customers for magazine subscription services. Handyman had yet to provide subscription services as of January 1. B. On April 30, Woodworking recognizes subscription revenues earned. C. On October 31, Woodworking recognizes subscription revenues earned. D. On December 31, Woodworking recognizes subscription revenues earned.arrow_forwardIt is February 16, 2020, and you are auditing Davenport Corporation's financial statements for 2019 (which will be issued in March 2020). You read in the newspaper that Travis Corporation, a major customer of Davenport, is in financial difficulty. Included in Davenports accounts receivable is 50,000 (a material amount) owed to it by Travis. You approach Jim Davenport, president, with this information and suggest that a reduction of accounts receivable and recognition of a loss for 2019 might be appropriate. Jim replies, Why should we make an adjustment? Ted Travis, the president of Travis Corporation, is a friend of mine; he will find a way to pay us, one way or another. Furthermore, this occurred in 2020, so lets wait and see what happens; we can always make an adjustment later this year. Our 2019 income and year-end working capital are not that high; our creditors and shareholders wouldnt stand for lower amounts than they already are. Required: From financial reporting and ethical perspectives, prepare a response to Jim Davenport regarding this issue.arrow_forward
- How much is the warranty expense for the year ended December 31, 2021? With the goal of attracting as much customers as possible in the CAR region, LISA Appliance Co. engaged in a customer satisfaction program and marketing strategy for two of their major lines of products: (1) electrical appliances and (2) household and office furniture. All branches in the region are participating in the company’s promotions. In the customer satisfaction program, LISA provides one-year warranty replacement of parts and labor of the electrical appliances sold. Based on past experience, the estimated warranty cost is 3% of sales. During 2021, total sales of electrical appliances was ₱7,200,000. Replacement parts and labor for warranty work totaled ₱184,000 during 2021. In the company’s marketing strategy for the household and office furniture section, customers are given a coupon for every ₱1,000 spent on these items. Customers may exchange 10 coupons plus ₱500 for a “hot and cold” water dispenser.…arrow_forwardEscargot Inc. is a 5-star restaurant in Cincinnati. The restaurant sells 500 gift cards during January 2019. Each gift card has a face value of $300. The gift cards never expire, although based on industry experience, Escargot expects that 12% of the balances will never be redeemed. During February 2019, $45,000 of gift cards are redeemed, and in March 2019 another $80,000 is redeemed. Required: 1. Prepare journal entries for Escargot’s gift card transactions for January through March. 2. Assume that at the end of April, due to the popularity of the restaurant, Escargot reduces its estimate of the amount of gift cards that will go unused to 8%. During April, gift cards worth $10,000 are used. Prepare any necessary journal entries.arrow_forwardMathys Inc. has recently hired a new independent auditor, Karen Ogleby, who says she wants “to get everything straightened out.” Consequently, she has proposed the following accounting changes in connection with Mathys Inc.'s 2020 financial statements. 1. At December 31, 2019, the client had a receivable of $820,000 from Hendricks Inc. on its balance sheet. Hendricks Inc. has gone bankrupt, and no recovery is expected. The client proposes to write off the receivable as a prior period item. 2. The client proposes the following changes in depreciation policies. a. For office furniture and fixtures, it proposes to change from a 10-year useful life to an 8-year life. If this change had been made in prior years, retained earnings at December 31, 2019, would have been $250,000 less. The effect of the change on 2020 income alone is a reduction of $60,000. b. For its new equipment in the leasing division, the client proposes to adopt the sum-of-the-years'-digits depreciation method. The…arrow_forward
- Intermediate Accounting: Reporting And AnalysisAccountingISBN:9781337788281Author:James M. Wahlen, Jefferson P. Jones, Donald PagachPublisher:Cengage LearningIndividual Income TaxesAccountingISBN:9780357109731Author:HoffmanPublisher:CENGAGE LEARNING - CONSIGNMENT
- Principles of Accounting Volume 1AccountingISBN:9781947172685Author:OpenStaxPublisher:OpenStax CollegeCornerstones of Financial AccountingAccountingISBN:9781337690881Author:Jay Rich, Jeff JonesPublisher:Cengage Learning