Concept explainers
As outlined in this chapter, sex can be defined at several levels: chromosomal, gonadal, and
An Indian athlete, Santhi Soundarajan, finished second in the 800-meter run at the Asian Games in Doha, Qatar, in 2006. After the race, she was asked to take a sex test. According to press reports, the tests showed that she “appeared to have abnormal chromosomes.” An official stated that she had more Y chromosomes than allowed. As a result, she was stripped of her medal, banned from further competition by the Indian Olympic Association, and shunned by her local community. Before the race in Doha, Santhi had competed in 8 international competitions and won 12 medals. Sometime after this incident, she attempted suicide. She now runs a training school for athletes in Tamil Nadu, India. Although the number and types of tests done on Santhi have not been revealed, such tests usually involve examination of the external genitals, a chromosome analysis, and measurement of hormone levels.
Suppose you were on the committee deciding whether Santhi could compete as a female. Consider each of the following hypothetical tests one at a time and base your conclusions only on the results of that test. The results of a physical examination show she has female genitals. On this basis, would you allow her to keep her medal and compete as a female in future races? Suppose the results of a chromosomal analysis shows that she has an XY chromosome set and is chromosomally male. Would you allow her to keep her medal and compete as a female? Lastly, suppose a test for hormone levels shows that she has levels of the male sex hormone testosterone that are higher than average for females but at least 10 times lower than the average for males. Would you allow her to keep her medal and compete in future races as a female? Now, put the results of all three tests together, and consider them as a whole. What are your conclusions?
Now, let’s consider the case of a South African runner, Caster Semenya, who won the 800-meter run at the World Championships held in Berlin, Germany, in 2009. After the race, she was asked to undergo sex testing. The IAAF stated that the tests were requested to ascertain whether she had a rare medical condition that gave her an unfair physical advantage. The nature of the tests and their results were not released, but press reports indicate that she did not have ovaries or a uterus, and had testosterone levels intermediate between the averages for males and females. In the end, the IAAF agreed to keep the results of her tests confidential, and Caster was allowed to keep her medal and return to international competition in 2010. In both cases, what the IAAF considers the threshold for determining who can compete as a female has not been stated.
Based on what is known about the test results in this case and the hypothetical tests in the first case, do you think the outcome in each case was fair?
To determine: Whether the outcome in each case was fair or not.
Introduction: Several methods of sex testing are used by the International Olympic Committee and the International Association of Athletics Federation to test the “femaleness” of female athletes and prevent the male athletes from cheating in the competition by competing as females. These tests depict several personal, legal and social issues, and have been condemned and defended widely.
Explanation of Solution
An Indian athlete, Santhi Soudarajan who won the second prize in the 800-meter race at the Asian Games in Doha, Qatar, in 2006 was asked to take a sex test whose results depicted that the athlete “appeared to have abnormal chromosomes” as it was found that the athlete had more Y chromosomes than allowed. The athlete was stripped of the medals won and was banned from competing in any further competitions by the Indian Olympic Association.
On the basis of the hypothetical tests, the athlete was found to be phenotypically female, had an XY set of sex chromosomes and had intermediate levels of testosterone. The outcome in the given case was unfair. The athlete had a medical disorder which may be partial or complete androgen insensitivity. The athlete should have been allowed to participate in the further competitions.
In the second case, where the South African runner, Caster Semenya underwent a sex test and was found to have an unfair physical advantage due to the intermediate testosterone levels. This provided the athlete with an added advantage over the other female candidates in the form of increased strength and power. The athlete was allowed to keep the medals and participate in further international competitions from 2010. The results, in this case, were fair as the athlete might have a certain medical disorder due to which the absence of ovaries and uterus was depicted. The testosterone levels were intermediate and the athlete could not compete with males because of depicting female phenotypic characteristics. It was justified to let her compete as a female in future competitions.
Thus, the results in the first case where the athlete was stripped of its medals were unjustified, whereas the results in the second case where the athlete was allowed to keep the medals and participate in future competitions were justified.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 7 Solutions
Human Heredity: Principles and Issues (MindTap Course List)
- In order for sexual intercourse to produce a pregnancy, both partners must experience _____. a. orgasm b. ejaculation c. affection d. none of the abovearrow_forwardPeople with androgen insensitivity syndrome show developmental abnormalities. Which of the following primary or secondary sexual characteristics is most likely to be seen in these individuals? The presence of: a prostate a penis breast development at puberty descended testes pubic and axillary hairarrow_forwardWhich of the following is true regarding the determinants of sexual development: the presence of the gene for HY antigen on the Y chromosome determines whether a testis develops from the gonadal ridge. the presence of MIS determines whether the Wolffian ducts develop. the presence of estrogen determines whether a vagina develops. the presence of DHT determines whether a prostate develops.arrow_forward
- According to the current scientific understanding of the topic, why is our gender identity is NOT a matter of choice?arrow_forwardIt has been suggested that looking for the presence of the SRY gene would be a better way of determining whether she is “male” or “female”. Is this accurate? Please explain. Also, does she possess ovaries? Testes? Both? Neither?arrow_forwardA girl attains her puberty at the age of 11 years and a boy at 13 years but, still they are asked to refrain from sex, why?arrow_forward
- T or F: The glans penis and the clitoris are always covered by a prepuce. The ovaries and the uterus are the primary female sex organs. Ejaculation is the discharge of semen from the erect penis. The labia minora of the female genitalia are homologous to the body of the penis Meiosis is unique to the gonads. Sympathetic stimulation of the arteries within the penis causes engorgement of the erectile tissue as arterial flow increases and venous drainage decreases. Mammary glands are modified sudoriferous glands. Prolactin causes the breasts to enlarge and the mammary glands to mature during puberty. Secretions from the vestibular glands moisten and lubricate the vaginal orifice during sexual arousal. 20. The secretory phase of menstruation is from the time of ovulation until the start of the menstrual phase.arrow_forwardWhich of the following is NOT one of the events leading to male sex-determination in humans? The Wolffian ducts are degraded. TDF and SF1 stimulate transcription of SOX9. Testosterone is produced, which stimulates the development of male reproductive structures and other male secondary characteristics. Mullerian-Inhibiting Hormone (MIH) is produced. The SRY gene is expressed to produce Testes-Determining Factor (TDF).arrow_forwardWhich of the following statement correctly describe the role of androgen in the male reproductive system? Select one: A. LH stimulates the Sertoli cell to produce inhibin and to start spermatogenesis. B. Increased levels of inhibin released by the interstitial cells result in lower levels of FSH and testosterone. C. Increased levels of testosterone feedbacks negatively to the anterior pituitary and hypothalamus. D. GnRH is released by the anterior pituitary and stimulates the release of FSH and LH.arrow_forward
- What is the difference between gender and sex? Is gender identity something that is genetic or it is shaped by culture and environment. How did the tragedy of the Reimer twins contribute to our understanding of gender identityarrow_forwardAside from the use of the condom, are there other male-centered methods of contraception that are recommended? (Silly ones with an ounce of scientific basis may be included!). Contraception is a seemingly gender-biased issue since most methods bear heavily on females to implement. Irregardless of your sex, would you recommend the use of male pills, or any of the methods Why or why not?arrow_forwardFour factors are considered when determining a person's biological sex.how each of these four factors is or is not likely to contribute to performance differences between sexesarrow_forward
- Human Heredity: Principles and Issues (MindTap Co...BiologyISBN:9781305251052Author:Michael CummingsPublisher:Cengage Learning
- Nutrition Through The Life CycleHealth & NutritionISBN:9781337919333Author:Brown, Judith E.Publisher:Cengage Learning,Human Physiology: From Cells to Systems (MindTap ...BiologyISBN:9781285866932Author:Lauralee SherwoodPublisher:Cengage LearningHuman Biology (MindTap Course List)BiologyISBN:9781305112100Author:Cecie Starr, Beverly McMillanPublisher:Cengage Learning