Ticking time bomb scenario

intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession” according to the Convention Against Torture. The legality of torture has been discussed within the international community multiple times creating multiple treaties. Such treaties came from the Geneva Convention and the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. While the countries who sign these treaties have an obligation to create effective

Dershowitz. Then identify and describe the critical issues addressed in the article. In your paper, thoroughly discuss and evaluate the following concepts: the ticking time bomb hypothesis; Dershowitz's comments regarding Jeremy Bentham as well as his comments about Voltaire's views; and the three ways to deal with the use of torture in the ticking time bomb situation, as stated by the Israeli government-appointed commission of the late 1980s. As part of the discussion about the commission's conclusions, include

torture. The argument presupposes that there is in fact a bomb and that the suspect detained has knowledge of the said bomb. However, if they know that it has been placed in and undisclosed location and it is yet to detonate one cannot be sure of its existence unless it goes off. Therefore, it is unethical to torture someone for something that one is uncertain whether it exists. The assumption that the suspect has the knowledge of preventing the bomb from exploding is very wrong because the suspect may

government use of torture during interrogation is ethically justifiable. The use of torture throughout Earth’s history gives evidence supporting torture for interrogation purposes. If you look at different time periods of the world, you will find that torture has been around for a very long time. The use of torture was handled differently in different eras but they all give evidence supporting that torture is ethically justifiable. A few important examples that show evidence

Using standard interrogation methods, the agents cannot get the terrorist to reveal the location of the “ticking bomb.” A ticking bomb scenario is when a terrorist claims to have set a bomb somewhere and there is a time limit. The “ticking bomb” hypothetical is often cited in discussions on torture. Many people believe that in such a situation, agents should do anything they can to find the bomb, including torturing the terrorist. Alan Dershowitz, a Harvard law professor, believes that in real life

(Stanford 1) Also, one might be able to analyze the cost-benefit analysis in a specific situation, but what about the next time? Known as ‘the calculation problem’, it states that because we cannot always weigh the ‘prerequisite to outcome’ ratio the same in all situations, it is impossible to make a morally permissible universal rule, in this case, regarding torture. (Jason

moral dilemma can be found in the ‘Ticking Time Bomb’ scenario—often presented as so: A perpetrator of an imminent terrorist attack, a bomb, that will kill many people, is in the hands of the authorities. He has been interrogated but to no avail. Authorities suspect that he will only disclose the information needed to prevent the attack if he is tortured. Should he be tortured? Firstly, it must be taken into consideration that there are a number of possible scenarios for the alleged terrorist of this

Gaul Rahman, a suspected Afghan radical, was arrested and brought to a CIA-run prison within six weeks of the 9/11 attacks. Rahman was detained for the purposes of providing inside information on the bombings, as well as to shed light on possible future terrorist attacks to be committed on United States soil. A month after his arrival at the prison, guards entered his cell to discover a gruesome sight. As quoted by the Senate Intelligence Committee Report on Torture, “In November 2002, Gaul Rahman

The thin line between humanity and safety has been blurred. The world stood in shock on September 11th 2001 when a terrorist group known as al-Qaeda hijacked four airliners and successfully flew two of them into the World Trade Centers in New York and one into the Pentagon. These atrocities resulted in the death of more than two thousand and seven hundred victims, including citizens from over eighty nations (9/11 Report). The magnitude of these attacks was unprecedented in the history transnational

kidnapping a little girl and putting her in a place where she will die if she is not rescued in a certain amount of time. Harry who pursues the kidnapper corners him, in which the kidnapper raises his arms to surrender. Harry shoots the kidnapper in the leg and asks him where the little girl is. The kidnapper avoids the question by answering only talking about his rights. Harry with very little time begins to put his foot on the kidnappers wounded leg in