Ticking time bomb scenario

for lives than without that information. Time could also be considered a great importance of using torture. When it comes to terrorist attacks, the CIA and the military think of it as a timely matter. They want to use torture as a type

Over the past fifty years, the United States has faced many foreign and domestic threats. Some of these have been successfully executed, such as the Oklahoma City bombing, the September 11th attacks, the Boston Marathon bombing, and the Las Vegas shooting. While it is nearly impossible for a country to avoid such attacks, it is the responsibility of the acting government to defend its its people from possible threats. Organizations such as the FBI, CIA, and Homeland Security have developed specific

from the techniques. Additionally, a study by the Center for the Study of Democracy found that public support actually collapsed when actual torture practices such as waterboarding and sexual humiliation were described, even in cases of "ticking time bomb" scenarios (CSD

Torture is a hugely controversial subject in our society today. Torture is defined as an intentional use of pain or abuse to gain an advantage over an individual. According to TheWeeklyStandard, torture is applied to prisoners or detained person to obtain admission of crime or to simply impose pain and suffering as a punishment (Krauthammer). Torture is also used to get information from the suspects by hurting them physically, mentally and emotionally. However, many argue that torture is against

Ten years ago on September 11th, terrorists successfully carried out a plan to kill thousands of innocent American civilians. On that day millions of Americans watched in horror and disbelief. How could something like this happen on American soil? In quick retaliation, President George W. Bush forcefully declared a war against terrorism and specifically against those responsible for the slaughter of his people, Al Qaida. At the head of this organization and architect of “9-11” was a man by the

utilitarian motivation to make lawful special cases. There is no space for exemptions because of the two fundamental arguments to the issue: The Ticking Bomb Situation (TBS), and torment creep. The ticking bomb situation, which asks: If a terrorist has planted a bomb in a building full of people, and refuses to confess where the bomb is hidden, given that there is no time to search the building nor to get all the people out to safety, is it acceptable to torture the terrorist in order to obtain that information

the ticking time bomb scenario. For there to be a justification for the necessity of torture to protect lives there must be six key items present: 1) There must be a planned attack. 2) The captive must know about the planned attack. 3) Torture must be the only way to obtain the information. 4) The captive must be persuaded to provide the information. 5) The information must be accurate. 6) If the information is obtained, there must be time and means to prevent the attack. The ticking time

This scenario proposes a situation in which a time limit is issued before an attack is carried out on the lives of many people. The primary issue arises when an individual from a conflicting party has the knowledge or capability to prevent the attack and refuses to reveal the solution

Taking a closer look into the moral reasoning behind torture, we use the theories of two philosophers, Kant and Mill, to determine whether or not torture is ever ethical. John Stuart Mill and Immanuel Kant, both proposed different philosophies, using deontological and teleological theories in ethics. John Stuart Mill used a teleological theory, which prioritized the end result of an action, based off the moral nature of the action itself, compared to the deontological theory proposed by Kant, which

should be illegal or accepted has yet to be reached. Still, the use of torture is necessary and is a key component in the defense of a nation. The use of torture has been known to affect both the interrogator and the person being interrogated. Over time people have taken an illogical perspective of the word, torture. It has rapidly spread worldwide and now affects nations as a whole. Human rights advocates and those who are easily disturbed or squeamish, have taken a negative view on the use of it