preview

9/11 Ethical Issues

Better Essays

On September 11, 2001, the world as Americans where familiar with changed forever. As one of the world’s great super power nations Americans were sure that no one would ever raise a hand against them. Even before that day attacks made on American were small, or thwarted, or the culprits were quickly named and brought to justice. The terrorists who attacked American that day changed the game book, changed the way Americans felt about their safety and began a war that has no real face, no easily identifiable agenda, and no quick ending in sight. To protect the country President George W. Bush signed into law the Patriot Act and help create the office of Homeland Security. Guantanamo Bay was deemed the place to hold those arrested for …show more content…

This was not just limited to known terrorists but to citizens arrested under suspicion of treason and even citizens of foreign countries arrested in their own countries and brought to the Bay. Regardless of one’s personal feelings towards those accused of terrorism, we must strive to protect all human rights and make sure those who are guilty are punished not the innocent. When it comes to the war on terrorism, both alien and citizen detainees have lost their rights to Habeas Corpus as well as any Constitutional rights based on the threat of invasion and public safety, nationality, and, in the case of citizens, treason against the States and people of America, but when one looks at American History we see this is neither ethically nor morally …show more content…

Many feel that this doctrine is one of “Mystical status” that allows researchers and students to act “romantic” about this “legendary writ” and review it “as another Magna Carta” (Crompton, 2014, pg. 50). However, the original function of this right was completely opposite of its modern use and began in Medieval times. The Latin translation is “you may have the body” and was used to bring the accused to jail to stand trial not to set them free. The right of Habeas Corpus is one of the greatest pieces of legislature to come out of the Renaissance era and throughout the growth of countries like Great Britain, the development of this writ not only affected the law itself but the jury system and the trial process also (Crompton, 2014, pg.51). When the colonists came over to America, they brought with them many of the laws and procedures with them. These laws became legitimate whenever the governor or crown appointed founder set foot in the new state. According to Wilkes in his article for The Georgia Law Review, “both common law habeas corpus and the 1679 English statute were received into the colony on Feburary12, 1733, the day General James Oglethorpe, the colony’s founder, first set foot in Georgia” (Wilkes, 2011, pg. 1020). Since Habeas Corpus was considered an Englishman’s longstanding common law right, it passed on to the colonists and all those born in the new colonies since they

Get Access