preview

Alice Munro Symbolism

Good Essays

As often as the lesson “don't judge a book by its cover” is reciprocated from generation to generation, it remains a cyclic tendency among human beings. Regardless of upbringing, socioeconomic status, or intention, at one point or another every person has made an assumption about someone else without knowing anything about them. Author Alice Munro illustrates this fact in her short story “Day of the Butterfly” as the protagonist, Helen, reflects upon a bold decision she made in middle school. Observing that one of her classmates, Myra Sayla, was being repeatedly teased by her peers, Helen makes a bold decision to seek the girl out. Little does she know the choice that she made on that cool winter morning would lead her on a journey she could …show more content…

Noticing that Myra had hardly touched the Cracker Jack, Helen decides to offer the girl some more. As Myra reaches into the box, she finds a prize: a gold-colored brooch in the shape of a butterfly (Munro 237). Holding it in her hand, the author notes a slight smile that crosses her face; the first smile observed since the beginning of the story. Helen offers to let the girl keep it, but Myra just stands there “scared and solemn”, almost as if she had never been on the receiving end of a kind gesture (Munro 238). In a way, this scene demonstrates that however pure one`s intentions are, one action can drive someone right back into the shell they originally tried to crawl out of. Nonetheless, they push past their discomfort and as Helen pushes the brooch back into Myra`s hand, the author describes the contact their fingers made- bolstering the evidence that these girls are forming a bond. It is during this part of the narrative that the title, “Day of the Butterfly”, is made significant. This scene is a turning point for both girls, for a friendship that holds beauty and potential has been …show more content…

Myra`s tone changes, however, when the students lay presents on her bed. Munro describes it as an “innocent look”, “a partial, private smile” that spread across her face, the second and last smile described in the story (Munro 240). Given the unfortunate state that Myra`s health is in, readers begin to feel the clock of Helen and Myra`s friendship tick. Throughout this passage, Myra appears to be especially calm, and even grateful for the moment, despite her current state. She addresses every individual by name and thanks them for their kind gift. Myra`s decision to thank each person individually is evidence of her attempt to be appreciative despite her current state and readers can sense the effort that the girl is making to hold on even if by a thread. As everyone says their goodbyes, Myra calls out to Helen. Asking her to take one of her gifts, Helen kindly rejects, but Myra insists she keep something. She places a small accessory bag in her hand and for the last time, their fingers touch. Myra says to Helen, “When I come back from London, you can come and play at my place after school” (Munro 240). Similar to when Helen told Myra that her “brother” was also shy in order to make her feel more comfortable about the situation, Myra`s

Get Access