preview

American Dilemma Summary

Decent Essays

In American Dilemma (1944), Gunnar Myrdal, a Swedish sociologist, writes about the economic conditions that plagued the Negro race in 1944 during World War II. According to Myrdal, “except for a small minority enjoying upper or middle-class status, the masses of American Negroes, in the rural South and in segregated slum quarters in Southern and Northern cities, are destitute. They own little property; even their household goods are mostly inadequate and dilapidate. Their incomes are not only low, but irregular. They live from day to day and have scant security for the future” (Katznelson 29).
The lived reality for African-Americans in the South constituted a bleak existence rooted in the “separate but unequal” practice of Jim Crow and limited …show more content…

Many Southern African-Americans were relegated to two industries—agricultural work and domestic labor. However, given the stronghold of Southern Democrats in Congress, these wage-laborers did not receive the same direct relief nor economic benefits as white laborers in the manufacturing or construction industries. Black farmers only held 63 acres of land to 145 acres for whites in 1935 (Katznelson 30). According to historian James McGovern, “the most abject of America’s rural people were the African-Americans who farmed in the South. Living conditions were wretched. Not even one in a hundred black farm families had cold or hot water piped into their homes” (Katznelson 32). In response to these bleak economic conditions, the positive rights rhetoric of the Economic Bill of Rights inspired Black voters to openly align themselves with the Democratic party—a party concerned with the poor, economic rights, and the expansion of federal power. African-American citizens, both in the North and the South, …show more content…

Philip Randolph penned the poignant speech “Why Should We March.” In his gripping speech, Randolph advocated for a desegregated military, the elimination of racist, discriminatory policies among employers, and withholding federal dollars from any contractor that practices discrimination (Randolph 351). His rhetoric for the March on Washington prompted a response from the federal government to institute Executive Order (8802), which banned anti-discrimination provisions for employers and instituted the Fair Employment Practices Commission (EPOC). The Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944, lauded as the first piece of colorblind federal legislation, provided veterans with tuition for education, housing loans, and business loans (Katznelson 118). However, while the Roosevelt administration enacted the policy, localities and states had to enforce the law. These localities restricted access to the G.I. Bill based on race and certain African-American industries (Katznelson

Get Access