preview

An Article On Human Rights

Better Essays

Right to Health
Simranjeet Singh
Georgian College
Human Rights (GNED2032)
Sean O’Hara
Friday, April 8, 2016

However, a few contradictions abound: as this article shows, rights discourse has been used to attempt to advance arguments that will actually allow access to private or semi-private health insurance in ways that may exacerbate disadvantage (Canada and Israel); it is used to expand access to medications to the middleclass, sometimes (arguably at least) at the expense of the poor (Brazil);7 and it competes with other rights (especially intellectual property within the trade regime).8 Also, there have been attempts (even if those ultimately failed) to use rights arguments in order to undermine the expansion …show more content…

deteriorate into a poor service for poor people.37 This will jeopardize access for the poor to needed health services.38 Indeed, the dissenting judges in Chaoulli emphasized that the Canada Health Act’s (CHA) policy is that health care will be provided based on need rather than on wealth or status and that the prohibition against private health insurance is a rational consequence of Quebec’s commitment to the CHA’s goals.39 They argued further that access to private health care based on wealth rather than need contradicts the CHA’s key policy

Get Access