preview

Analysis Of Hardy 's ' The Best Hope Ever Sown '

Decent Essays

In the third stanza, Hardy states: “But not so. How arrives it joy lies slain / And why unblooms the best hope ever sown?” Immediately in this stanza, he realizes that there is no point to human pain and suffering, because he can 't find evidence that humans ' pain has meaning to God. He dismisses the idea brought about by the first two stanzas, and admits his faith in meaning is crushed. He’s lost his hope that he’s held onto for so long, and there’s no “joy” left. He comments that his hope was “the best hope ever sown” because belief in the significance and universal importance of human life was a beautiful lie spread throughout humanity. However, the third line of the poem reads: “—Crass Casualty obstructs the sun and rain,” symbolizing happiness and optimism, which are obstructed by the reality that nothing happens for a reason. The sun and rain he mentions represent the beautiful, seemingly significant things in life. However, the love and the beauty the narrator has experienced are all rendered meaningless by the insignificant misery of his lifetime. The “Crass Casualty” is the inane and pointless pain he’s experienced, along with every other human who has lived on earth. The worst part is that the pain lacks an origin of reason, and doesn’t matter to whatever God Hardy wants to believe in. Scholar E. S. Ownbey discusses how Hardy struggled to conform to the religious expectations of his time. He says that “a number of Thomas Hardy’s poems are built on

Get Access