preview

Analysis Of Shakespeare's The Rape Of Lucrece

Better Essays

Scholarly work on the perennial problem of rape has traditionally placed the blame of perpetuation on the flaws inherent in patriarchal systems. Some scholars have pointed to the constructed gender hierarchies of patriarchy as fertile grounds for rape to flourish (Pallotti 218). Shakespeare’s The Rape of Lucrece is often read this way, with an emphasis on how Tarquin’s construction of Lucrece’s femininity—as whole and inaccessible—is what motivates his rape (Quay 7). Other scholarship suggests that gaps in sex crime laws are responsible for the perpetuation of rape (Decker and Baroni 1167). This argument highlights the lack of legislative contrast between The Rape of Lucrece’s setting in ancient Rome, the monarchial republic of …show more content…

Today, the well-intentioned hyperfocus on consent in rape cases has actually led to a submersion of agency beneath context or structure (Munro 420). And if the Harvey Weinstein allegations have taught us anything, it is that consent is still undervalued in contemporary America. Some scholarship has even claimed that non-consent is valorized by our society (Oliver 4).
With alarming consistency across centuries, sexual and political consent have been limited, undermined, or generally devalued. In Shakespeare’s poem, Lucretia’s interactions with her two servants—one female and one male—serve to expose the paradox of consent: that a servant’s consent is not explicitly valued, yet the very power of his or her master is dependent upon such consent. This paradox is applicable across patriarchal systems including monarchy and, ironically, republicanism. In a republic, freeborn-slave or male-female dynamics take the place of the master-servant relationship portrayed by Lucretia and her servants. I will argue that this paradox of consent is the basis for the devaluation of consent in The Rape of Lucrece, and by extension in republicanism; and that this devaluation results in the gender hierarchies, gaps in sex crime laws, and disproportionate representation that perpetuate rape. The Rape of Lucrece’s first significant interaction between Lucretia and her maid justifies the devaluation of female consent by constructing femininity

Get Access