preview

Analysis Of The Story ' Girl '

Decent Essays

This Is How
“Girl” is a succession of instructions from a mother to a daughter – instructions on how to do house chores, on suitable clothing to wear, on walking and behaving like a lady, on gardening, on ironing and hemming, on playing marbles with boys, on fishing, on getting a man, on cooking, on how to “spit in the air if you feel like it”. Not only is the voice in the story intended to help the daughter, it is also told to scare and scold her. The writing brings to life a world where okra can grow too close to the house, where there are red ants to worry about and benna songs to sing in Sunday school, where learning to fish is as important as how to make medicine “to throw away a child before it becomes a child”.
The short story is …show more content…

Underlying consequences are made apparent because it is not a “you should” statement; it is a “this is how”, as if there is only one correct way.
The voice in the story is stern and commanding, tolerating no backtalk. However, there seems to be times that the validity of the mother’s voice is sincere and her intent is being undermined. Two different times, the daughter tries to express her voice, resisting the mother’s scolding, but it is not clear where the daughter’s voice is coming from. Although the girl is physically absent though out the short story, her underlying presence is strong; the kind of presence that possibly suggests the girl and the narrator are potentially one in the same.
Or, is it the Girl who is narrating and working out her own identity though speaking, recreating and re-enacting the complicated relationship with her mother, the complicated identity of learning how to be a woman, a reenactment through assembling the severe and protective and loving and damning instructions on how to be? Nonetheless, the Girl defended herself and stuck up for herself on two separate occasions. “But I don’t sing benna on Sundays at all and never in Sunday school…” and “…Always squeeze the bread to make sure it’s fresh; but what if the baker won’t let me feel the bread?; you mean to say that after all you are really going to be the kind of woman who the

Get Access