preview

Analysis Of Walt Whitman 's Song Of Myself

Satisfactory Essays

Vera Lee Prof. Noel Dolan ACS-Moderns 30 March 2017 “Ne Te Quaesiveris Extra” But Write a Poem Using the Same Ideas from Another Person The idea that the artist is a single individual coming to stand and speak for the masses is one of Emerson’s main transcendentalist ideas. Walt Whitman met Emerson’s ideal artist description as he spoke as one man for the multitude in his poem, “Song of Myself”, which openly demonstrates Whitman’s faith in the imperative indivisibility of self-reliance. He shares many of the same ideas as Emerson, such as the importance of the self and views on religion. There are some differences in certain ideas, images and the language; however, these differences do not take away from Whitman’s fulfillment of …show more content…

The self, a physical presence as a projected possibility, that Whitman celebrates proves to be evocative, multiform, and full of contradictions. This is Emerson’s self-reliant man existing not in isolation but in ensemble. Religion, according to Emerson, needs self-reliance in order to turn a person’s mind from trivial and egotistical desires to benevolent wishes for the betterment of society. All religion can and do propose new ideas and thoughts to an individual, but the substitution of independent thoughts [required for the self-reliant person] for ready answers makes religion dangerous for Emerson’s vision of the self. Religion 's main problem, according to Emerson, is its likeliness to opt for imitation because of its fear of the individual’s creativity. "Everywhere I am hindered of meeting God in my brother, because he has shut his own temple doors, and recites fables merely of his brother 's, or his brother 's brother 's God” (Emerson). Whitman also makes note of the problems with religion in section 5 of his poem “Song of Myself”, “And I know that the hand of God is the promise of my own, And I know that the spirit of God is the brother of my own”. Through the evidence of overlapping ideas, it is evident that Whitman does embody Emerson’s ideal of “self-reliance”. Even though Whitman’s poem fulfills Emerson’s vision of self as true to inner voice and purpose, Whitman’s ideas, languages, and images do not all coincide with

Get Access