preview

Arnstein's Ladder Summary

Better Essays

Stein's article examines media participation in the domain of user policies and agreements since they are crucial structural factors conditioning user participation. She states that understanding the terms of participation is important because it acts legal agreement associate with the institutional power and functioned as guidelines for lay users. In addition, the terms of participation in media and communication system are pivotal components to construct for democratic societies. Stein also introduced Arnstein's typology of participation and related it to the understanding of how user policy conditions the terms of media participation. Then, she addressed three criticisms on Arnstein's Ladder. Finally, Stein presented her own fixed vision …show more content…

At the bottom of the ladder are forms of nonparticipation or participation with no influence or power. In the middle is those people whom "participating participation" but do not guarantee their opinions and voices will be heard by power holders. At the top of the ladder are forms of participation that include formalized decision-making power and citizen control. Then, Stein pointed out three major criticisms of Arnstein's ladder. First, its close identification of participation with decision-making power rules out the informal ways where interaction may influence policies and transform power relations. Second, the ladder's value-laden ordering and labeling of participatory types disapproves participation types and restrains decisions to deploy them. Third, the ladder is missing rungs that related to the aims of …show more content…

One of the theories emphasize on social media as platforms for gathering news and information. It states that news on social media may be more influential on users because they are spread through trusted relationships, such as friends and family members. This theory also claims that more social media use would result in more participation in civic and political life. For example, those who use social media frequently will learn more about current events and are more likely to be politically knowledgeable and engaged. Another theory pays attention on the mobility of social media in creating social networks. It states, "Larger network can increase exposure to information about how and why a citizen should become active. (Bouianne, 2015)" In addition, larger network can facilitate information exchange in political life. Other research focuses on the relationship between social media and political or activist organizations. For instance, it believes that people belong to a certain organizations are more likely to volunteer in political activity because they have more chances of being asked to volunteer from other group members. Moreover, some other research examines the questions that how online behavior could affect on one's own decision. Based on these theories and data collection, author's metadata analysis demonstrates a positive relationship between social media use and

Get Access