preview

Centralia

Better Essays

Centralia No.5: A Mine Tragedy That Didn’t Have to Happen Tisa S. Frederick Strayer University PAD500016VA016-1126-001 (Modern Public Administration) Dr. Joseph Keller July 22, 2012 Centralia No.5: A Mine Tragedy That Didn’t Have To Happen On March 25, 1947, the mining world in the city of Centralia, Illinois was forever changed. This was the day 111 miners lost their lives, in Centralia No. 5, due to the neglect and disregard of the safety issues that were presented to those, for five (5) years, that were supposed to protect them. The blame lies at the feet of many. A few of them …show more content…

The dusty conditions of the mine and blasting procedures were contrary to the State mining law and to the Federal Mine Safety Code under which the mine was being operated by the Coal Mines Administration (Ankeny, Gallagher, Malesky, Perez, & Smith, 2012). Path 1 Scanlan could have and should have shut the mine down! When he continued to get there run around form his superiors. “Scanlan repeatedly told state officials and mine owners of the dangers to safety in the mine and pleaded for corrective action. Unfortunately, his efforts were ignored. Scanlan’s experience reminds us of the futility of being a single warning voice in a highly politicized system” (Hartley & Kenney, 2006). Although he had the authority to take matters into his own hands but he did not. I don’t know if this was out of fear that he would lose his job but as a public official it was his job to protect the people and he did not. Path 2 Scanlan should have gone to Governor Green himself. When Director Medill and others continually pushed his issues aside he should have taken the initative and taken the issue to the Governor himself. Considering Governor Green had promised the miners that he would enforce the mining law “to the letter of the law” (Stillman, p.32). Knowing the Governors stance on the mining laws he probably would have been open to the discussion. Scanlan kept telling Director Medill “to improve conditions which constituted an

Get Access