preview

Cit Fraud Case Paper

Better Essays

MODULE 3: CIT CASE QUESTIONS 1. The three aspects of fraud - Perceived pressure, Rationalization, and Opportunity were present in the CIT case as follows: Pressure- Niakan was placed under much pressure to meet monthly targets. The senior VP Ms. Thompson had earlier criticized his performance when it fell below expectations. Niakan had also been warned in his 2002 annual review that his team needed to improve end of lease sales and inventory returns. Apart from this work angle Niakan had personal financial pressures too; he and his wife had been through several rounds of expensive in vitro fertilization treatments before they had their twins. Opportunity- Niakan was responsible for the Remarketing department that Werle managed and the …show more content…

5. The 5 control components of COSO are: a. Control Environment- Although there were controls in place at CIT; it was a common practice to override the establishes controls. This component of COSO includes the ‘tone at the top”. If there had been a set rigid rule established by the top-level management then Niakan would not have had any excuse to override the controls. b. Risk Assessment- c. Control Activities- there were no controls in place at CIT to oversee Niakan’s work and question his decisions. d. Information and Communication- e. Monitoring- Niakan’s actions and decisions were not supervised; he had total liberty to make contracts with any companies as he pleased. Had there been better monitoring of his duties then it would have deterred him from committing fraud. 6. Although the dollar amount of the stolen components may not be a significant percentage of CIT’s net income such fraud has a ripple effect for the organization. The type of fraud that occurred at CIT is misappropriation of assets; this results in incorrect financial statements and in turn lead to incorrect publication of earning and annual report, as CIT is a public company. 7. Werle used Digital Analysis technique to uncover this fraud. She conducted computerized analytical review. She also conducted in depth research to investigate irregular activities and contracts that could have been entered in to by

Get Access