Many rescue services workers die while trying to save people who put themselves at risk .The reasons why they shouldn't have the rights to get rescued is that they're putting the rescue workers in danger. And climbers can take advantage of rescue services. People who put themselves at risk should not have the rights to get rescued. First of all, is because climbers take advantage of rescue services. In the article ''Why Everest'' it says. ''One thing to bear in mind is that climbers not only have to reach the summit safely, they also have to make their way back down. By that time their tired''. This quote shows that if their goal was to reach the summit they might feel lazy and not want to climb down on their own. The climbers might take advantage of rescue services in that situation. …show more content…
In the article ''Helicopter Rescues Increasing on Everest'' it says. '' Well, it turns out that helicopter rescues have been increasingly common in the mountains of Nepal. And that has raised a lots of questions about risk-taking-not just for climbers but for pilots, too''. And this shows that not on are the climbers at risk but the pilots too. The pilots are also at risk and can
The entire journey up the mountain is full of danger. You constantly have to worry about the oxygen you are getting and people around you are dying. The air is thin and if there is any air, it’s contaminated. You have to worry about getting the disease H.A.P.E. You have to worry about your health 24/7. You have to get past impossible obstacles. You just have to be strong. Climbing the mountain is an endless, painful battle. No matter what is happening outside of the mountain, on Mount Everest all that matters is Survival.
In order to continue climbing Everest, many aspects of climbing need to be improved before more people endanger their lives to try and reach the roof of the world. The guides have some areas that need the most reform. During the ascension of Everest the guides made a plethora mistakes that seemed insignificant but only aided in disaster. The guides first mistake is allowing “any bloody idiot [with enough determination] up” Everest (Krakauer 153). By allowing “any bloody idiot” with no climbing experience to try and climb the most challenging mountain in the world, the guides are almost inviting trouble. Having inexperienced climbers decreases the trust a climbing team has in one another, causing an individual approach to climbing the mountain and more reliance on the guides. While this approach appears fine, this fault is seen in addition to another in Scott Fischer’s expedition Mountain Madness. Due to the carefree manner in which the expedition was run, “clients [moved] up and down the mountain independently during the acclimation period, [Fischer] had to make a number of hurried, unplanned excursions between Base Camp and the upper camps when several clients experienced problems and needed to be escorted down,” (154). Two problems present in the Mountain Madness expedition were seen before the summit push: the allowance of inexperienced climbers and an unplanned climbing regime. A third problem that aided disaster was the difference in opinion in regards to the responsibilities of a guide on Everest. One guide “went down alone many hours ahead of the clients” and went “without supplemental oxygen” (318). These three major issues: allowing anyone up the mountain, not having a plan to climb Everest and differences in opinion. All contributed to the disaster on Everest in
This is corresponding to today’s community because if the climbers are unskilled and they are not sure about safety, then they must not go mountain climbing, if they die their family and friends will be sad also the rescuer may die too. There have been over 230 deaths on the mountain. It’s very dangerous! what if the accident happen? People never know what will happen in the future. Think before you do something! Undoubtedly, people do not have the right to rescue services when they put themselves at
The second reason people have the right to rescue services when they put themselves at risk is mountain climbing is difficult
“Don't be afraid to have a reality check. Taking risks is OK, but you must be realistic.” Joy Mangano. This proves that although risk-taking can be accepted, you must be experienced in the risk that you’re taking in order to be safe. My first source, Helicopter Rescues Increasing on Everest is transcribed from Robert Siegel’s radio show, and is a nonfiction radio interview whose purpose is to inform readers. Another source I analyzed is “Why Everest?” The article was authored by Guy Moreau and is a nonfiction article that is meant to inform readers. The third source I researched is Ranger Killed During Rescue of Climbers on Mount Rainier and is a nonfiction newspaper article meant to inform readers. The author of the article is The Seattle Times. People do not have the right to rescue services when they put themselves at risk because it puts more people at risk, it is cost-heavy, and because they choose to risk their lives.
Imagine someone swinging by a rope as they’re mountain climbing. Will anyone help? More and more people are climbing Mt. Everest so, the risk involved and increasing death tolls are very dangerous. And the helicopters are very expensive, almost $2 million. It’s dangerous for the helicopters to go up to the height of Everest or even just really high because if there is more than one person, it would have to go back and forth because it can one person. People do not have the right to rescue services when they put themselves at risk because we cannot afford it.
Mt. Everest’s summit has always seemed an unattainable goal for most people. The idea that most people have is that if I can climb Mt Everest, I can accomplish anything. To have the money and desire to try to attempt it is one thing, but being able to endure the punishment is quite another. Beck Weathers, one of the climbers on this particular expedition, had such severe frostbite that he had to have his right arm, nose and the fingers on his left hand amputated. Everyone on the expedition suffered the rigors of Everest. The two expert guides, Rob Hall and Scott Fischer, lost their lives due to a violent storm that ripped through during their descent from the summit. Their impaired judgment also contributed to their demise. Everest is no respecter of persons. Mt Everest is the most respected mountain in the whole world and if
Did you know that over two-hundred thirty deaths have happened on Mount Everest and that rescue services have only successfully removed thirty bodies? Those people died because they were unprepared by not having enough oxygen or they didn’t plan accordingly. Being unprepared, not being physically fit, and putting other people at risk are three reasons why I think that Rescue Services should not be allowed for people who put themselves at risk.
Can you save other people’s lives when you are in danger or close to death? I would say “No” most of the time because my life is the most important thing in the universe at least for me. This is a quite difficult and controversial question, but I assume that the majority of people would say no as well. I don’t understand why the climbers take risks that they can die.
Not only climbing Mount Everest can affect the climber, environment, but it can affect the local population of Nepal. According to the textbook Geography Alive! Regions and People it says on page 422 “ Porters are sometimes overworked and they are mistreated.” It is clearly testified that not everyone is nice to the porters, when they are only trying to help the climber climb safe to the summit. Another evidence, on page 216 from the book Peak, where it says “I had seen a dead person, let alone a frozen dead person.” Peak has testified that he saw a corpse just laying down face down on the cold snow on camp 4. This was new to him because he was not expecting this new thing for him. Concluding with this, climbing Mount Everest is not the best
And they got one climber off, and they crashed attempting to rescue the second man” (Helicopter Rescues Increasing on Everest 7). It is a rescuer’s job to know the risks for saving a climber but if the climber is a professional, they shouldn’t be easily be making mistakes. When there are rescuers who come pick you up fast when you can’t complete the climb, it is like having a safety net behind you. But where is the safety net behind the rescuers? There isn’t one, once they make a mistake, there won’t be someone to save them, so there shouldn’t be rescuers saving climbers when they are risking their own lives but also the
Yes, I believe people should have the right to rescue services even if they put themselves at their own risks for multiple reasons. My first reason is that it’s their job to protect and serve everyone including people who put themselves at their own risk. The next reason is everyone is always putting themselves at their owns risks when they step outside the door. My final reason is service members want to help all people. Have you ever wondered why rescue services exist?
Source #3 states that, some climbers who had fallen and slipped into a crevasse in the mountains. The two climbers were then pulled to safety at around 3:10pm. Source #3 concludes by saying this, “They had a few injuries from slipped and having around a hundred pounds yank on the harnesses, but none of the injuries received were life threatening.” Lately, since the many injured climbers tourists often point out the increase of helicopters flying in the sky. Details in source #3 clearly suggest services should not be provided for anyone who decides to put themselves at risk.
First of all the people should not be allowed rescue services because the climbers should know what they are getting themselves into and that they put their lives and the rescuers at risk of death. In the article "Ranger killed during rescue of climbers on mount rainier" it said. " Nick Hall a climbing ranger at mount rainier national park, fell 3,700 feet to his death Thursday afternoon, after helping rescue two climbers." ( The Seattle Times pg. 28). The quote shows that the rescuers could die when saving people which causes more people to die in total. Rescue
Every year thousands of mountaineering accidents occur. Most of all accidents come from slipping or falling. The second reasoning for accidents also comes from being unsafe and putting yourself in danger. Although, most accidents come from climbers themselves , there is still a portion of accidents that can’t be prevented. Mountain climbing can be safe under different circumstances.