preview

Cognitive Behavioral Approach For Older Adults

Decent Essays

Sheryl Green and colleagues designed a cognitive behavioural approach to pain specifically tailored to the needs of older adults. The sample consisted of 46 seniors in the treatment group and 49 in the control (Green, Hadjistazropoulos, Hadjistavropoulos, Martin, & Sharpe, 2009). In the treatment group, participants were given a 10-week pain management program with a cognitive behavioural orientation. The treatment was standardized according to a manual that described the goals and targets of each session. Several measures of pain, including the Geriatric Pain Measure (GPM), the Modified Pain Beliefs Questionnaire (PBQ), the Pain Severity Subscale of the Multidimensional Pain Inventory - Section 1 (MPI), the Shortened Daily Hassles Scale …show more content…

All the studies used different measurement tools to measure the psychological aspects of pain, so the review only focused on the physical reported outcomes of pain (Harris et al., 2015). Therefore, the review failed to examine other aspects of pain, as pain is not only a physical experience. The studies found that CBT was statistically “more effective compared to a waiting list in reducing headache intensity in one out of two studies, and in two other studies, reducing headache frequency and headache-free days”(Harris et al., 2015). There is a variety of problems with this review and the studies included within it. The quality between each of the studies varied and therefore, requires the results to be considered with caution due to the potential risk of bias. Furthermore, due to “methodology inadequacies in the evidence base, it makes it difficult to draw any meaningful conclusions or to make any recommendations” (Harris et al., 2015). The review also included older studies, ones that have a high risk of bias, studies with small sample sizes, and ones with “suboptimal reporting” (Harris et al., 2015). Other problems included that “selection bias is unknown or likely in all of these studies”, drop-outs were excluded in a number of the studies, problems with low participant numbers, and “there was a failure to report p values in a number of instances and two

Get Access