preview

Comment On Cristina 's Character Is She A Saint Or A Sinner?

Satisfactory Essays

Clara (DAO Thi Huong Giang)
Mrs. Dhar
English 4U – Lives of the Saints Seminar Assignment
12 November 2015

Topic 24: Comment on Cristina’s character. Is she a “saint” or a “sinner”?

Nino Ricci once said, “One cannot draw a clear dividing line between what is morally right and morally wrong.” In his first novel Lives of the Saints, there are of a lot of ethical ambiguities about the way Cristina behaves and what she believes. It can be said that in the strictest, specialized terms of Catholicism, the religion of Valle del Sole, she is a sinner; meanwhile as a renegade, in Marxism, she 's carrying on and acting in the spirit of sainthood. As a sinner with an egotistical personality, not only has she committed adultery but she also goes against every dogmatic rule that other villagers follow. Then again, she is a strong-minded woman who dares to be different, to follow her own beliefs and lead a free life in the way that no one in her village dares. Or maybe, she is just a woman living out of her time.
In terms of religion, Cristina is a heathen. Undoubtedly, she has broken one of the Ten Commandments of God, “You shall not commit adultery” (Deuteronomy 5), when she betrays her husband by having an affair with the mysterious “blue-eyed” German soldier. It appears that she has been cheating on him for quite a while, as “letters came to her every few months” (Ricci 2), before she is caught by Vittorio in the stable. After the incident in which she has sex with him and is

Get Access