preview

Comparing Horace's Satire In On Discontent And Modern Times

Decent Essays

Horace was an ancient Roman satirist and author of many satires including “On Discontent” located in Book I Satire I, which speaks to many issues of his time through rough criticism masked under dark humor that is followed with moral alternatives. Charlie Chaplain’s work in “Modern Times” is a satirical piece where Chaplain shows his discontent on new technology that’s displacing him and fellow actors out of work. The two satirical works contrast each other in their objectives but share the idea of the “poor man” in both works.

Horace finds great trouble with people who seem to never be pleased with what they have and his satire speaks out to this discontent. People that complain and always feel as if others have it better are viewed as …show more content…

Being presented with their wishes of trading spots the two sides “…refuse, on the verge of bliss.”. Dramatic irony is being used by Horace to transmit the inefficiency that these action less discontent people create. Horace displays how these members of society only speak and complain and have nothing enlightening or useful to say. Never pleased these people are always on the move for more. More money, gold and silver and more harvest surplus is what drives the lives of such members and no matter how much they acquire they still feel inadequate and seeking for addition. Horace is directly speaking out to people like Charlie Chaplin whose movie “Modern Times” is directly speaking to Chaplin’s discontent of the new technology that’s changing the industry. Anti-technology ideals are visually displayed in many scenes in the movie; one being when the factory attempt to introduce new and more efficient “feeding machines” that allow workers to maintain their productivity at work meanwhile being fed therefore removing the need for a break. Consequently, the machine intrudes and diminishes the ability of the worker

Get Access