preview

Comparing Romeo And Juliet By David Campton's Us And Them

Decent Essays

In many situations, the repetition of history can be observed, sometimes continuing indefinitely and sometimes eventually breaking the cycle. David Campton’s play Us and Them tells of two warring groups in an intentionally vague setting while Romeo and Juliet is a film directed by Baz Luhrmann that follows two rival families in 1996 Verona Beach while still retaining the original dialogue from William Shakespeare’s tragedy. Both of these texts remind the reader of how history repeats itself, however while Us and Them depicts history as a cycle that goes on continually, Romeo and Juliet shows how such patterns can eventually come to an end. In some instances, certain events serve as a reminder that history often repeats itself in a pattern that …show more content…

In Romeo and Juliet, the youngest generations of the Montague and Capulet families partake in “the continuance of their parents’ rage”. This shows that the conflict and hatred between these groups is not actually their own, but rather one that has been passed down and therefore repeated throughout an unknown number of generations. From this “ancient grudge breaks new mutiny” in the form of violent shootouts that “have thrice disturbed the quiet of [the] streets”. This suggests that the main way in which Luhrmann reminds the audience of the repetition of history is using the theme of conflict, and more specifically through physical violence and death. Unlike in Us and Them, Romeo and Juliet “do with their death bury their parents’ strife”. This is significant because it shows, that through their own deaths, Romeo and Juliet were able to break the cycle of conflict and hate and thus put an end to the repetition of hatred throughout histories of the two families. Luhrmann seems to have used Romeo and Juliet to not only show how history repeats itself but also the way in which such repetition can be potentially put to an end, however comparing the film to Us and Them will highlight some of the specific ways in which such repetition can

Get Access