preview

Comparing Why The Geese Shrieked And Yentl The Yeshiva Boy

Decent Essays

Nobody ever said life is easy. In fact, it’s really about proving you can face challenges. This is evident in Isaac Bashevis Singer’s short stories “Why the Geese Shrieked” and “Yentl the Yeshiva Boy”. Although The Mother, Yentl, and Hadass, the female characters of these stories, live in different places during different times, they all face challenges of gender.
The situations that these characters encounter are quite different, at least on the outside. Mother is a rationalist and the wife of a mystic rabbi. She suggests that there must be a logical explanation for this sound because “slaughtered geese don’t shriek” but her husband thinks there must be some supernatural explanation as to why they are making this noise. As a woman, Mother cannot outwardly express her disbelief that the reason for these shrieking geese is some sort of mystical source without the permission of her husband. In contrast, Yentl, the main character of “Yentl the Yeshiva Boy,” is in love with learning but is forbidden to do so by Jewish law. She has chosen to disguise her …show more content…

Mother stops to talk to the neighbor, asking her “did you remove the windpipes to these geese?” The woman says “no”. This information changes Mother’s thinking. She reaches her hand in the geese’s body and pulls out the windpipe, performing an experiment to show that this is why the geese were shrieking. She discovered the mystery behind the shrieking geese, helped a neighbor, and nicely proved that there must be a logical explanation for unusual events in the world. Yentl, too, confronts her problem. She acknowledges that “[she] wasn’t created for plucking feathers and chattering with females” and therefore does something about it. She uses her disguised appearance and mannerisms as a way of continuing her studies and cooping with her struggle of gender identity. She knows she will “live out [her] time as [she]

Get Access