preview

Comparing and Contrasting The Speckled Band and The Lamb to the Slaughter

Good Essays

The speckled band and the lamb to the slaughter are both a comparison of two short stories from the murder mystery genre. The speckled band was written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (in 1892 and was published in the following year). The lamb to the slaughter was written by the famous Roald Dahl (in 1953). Arthur was a Scottish physician and writer, he wrote a series of books featuring Sherlock Holmes and his side-Kick Dr. Watson. The stories were a big hit, the speckled band was also one of his adventurous chronicles. The lamb to the slaughter was a story written for older children and was also, satisfactory. Roald Dahl was an author and an intelligence officer –he was most famous for his great storytelling-His short stories are known for …show more content…

In conclusion I would side with Mary to be the perfect killer, as she did commit a crime of passion and almost planned the perfect alibi inorder to be proved innocent, she also discretely disposes of the weapon, which she used to kill her husband. Considering that, Dr. Grimesby was doing the complete opposite, he used his snake (The speckled band) to poison his step daughters, however they both knew that it was his house pet, which he had brought from India, therefore he would automatically be suspected as the murderer.

In the speckled band the detectives showed a lot of empathy towards Mary as they were her husband’s work colleagues, they also consumed food within the crime scene, which was breaking the rules, therefore with their own mistakes they ate the weapon (leg of lamb) and they weren’t as effective as they should’ve been, whereas they were liable, to being the ones to help destroy the weapon. They were more sympathetic. Comparing that to Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, who were more dedicated to their work, they prepared carefully inorder to work out the criminal mentality.

In my opinion, I prefer the lamb to the slaughter because, in the speckled band there was not much suspense surrounding the murderer, there was a constant trail of hints, the clues turned out to be rather obvious, it was the stepfather, we also knew that the murderer would have been caught when Sherlock Holmes laid out his trap. In the lamb to the

Get Access