Introduction:
Athens and Sparta were two city states in Ancient Greece. These city states worked to build a successful nation of freedom from outside rulers, in hopes of being a well-functioning society. The two city states had varied approaches in their desire for successful governments. Athens held a more democratic approach to government while Sparta held a monarchical or dictatorship government.
How did people in Athens and Sparta obtain the right to participate in public life and make decisions affecting the community?
Spartans obtained the right to participate in public life by performing the tasks that the government and society viewed as important. For the men, the culture valued strength, tenacity and vigilance. For the women, the culture valued ferocity, and the ability to have and care for many children, preferably boys. “The sole purpose of a Spartan man was to be a soldier and the only duty of a Spartan woman was to give birth to many more soldiers”(Brand pg. 1). If the babies were inferior, ill or too small then Spartan Elders ordered the babies be killed by throwing them into a ravine (Brand pg.6) Who held public office?
Spartan male warriors were the only people in their society that participated in politics (Brand pg. 7). The women, slaves or Periokoi - free men living under Spartan jurisdiction - were not allowed to participate in politics (Brand pg. 3). The Spartan’s government consisted of two kings, an assembly, an elder council called the Gerousia and
The city-states Athens and Sparta were rivals in ancient Greece. Geographically the two were very close to each other, but they had a very different economy, cultural values, and way of governing. Both city-states had two very different ways of doing things. I will be highlighting the major differences.
“The City of Sparta lies in the valley of the River Eurotas. Along with having a river close by; the Spartans were also enclosed by the mountains of Taygetos to the West and Parnon to the East.” Their society was a slave based culture, which allowed the Spartans to become the only full time fighting force in Ancient Greece. Their society was manned by two kings; one of which took the reins of the army in times of conflict or war, while the other king remained in Sparta and maintained society. However, the kings did not have complete power in ancient Sparta. They took two of the 30 seats of the gerousia, or the council of elders; this council of elders prepared possible legislation such as declaring war for a citizen assembly to reject or accept.
Athens is more superior than Sparta through, government, economy, and culture. Athens government is a democracy which means all citizens get to take part. In Athens “ all men are on an equality” which means “ Not of the few but of the many” (doc 3 pericles). Every citizen in Athens is allowed to take part in government, even poor citizens. Unlike Sparta, who has an oligarchy, monarchy, and democracy. The Spartan government is made up of kings and elders only. Not everyone gets to participate.
Spartan’s government was far superior to the government of Athens. Sparta had elements of an oligarchy. The two rulers were a piece of the administration for convention were the Council of Elders, or Gerousia, a gathering of twenty-eight Spartiate men and the two lords that who make charges, that the Assembly, or basic man, vote on. . There were broad governing rules to ensure that no part, or branch, turned out to be too intense. The Assembly was made out of each mature male in Sparta, yet hypothetically anyone could take part. They voted whether to pass bills into law, and against normal conviction, they could vote more than yes or no. These individuals from the Assembly were picked, by the fair evaluators, who sat in an alternate room and tuned in for the loudest cheer for every hopeful. This technique gave everyone a shot, and in the event that you truly needed a specific competitor, you could simply shout louder. The Ephors, were a gathering of five individuals, who settled on everyday choices, and were chosen yearly.
Spartan government, in contrast, is oligarchical. People were most often brought into slavery as a result of being conquered in battle, however some were brought in to battle through their familial lineage. Upon being brought in to slavery, a Spartan slaves’ main duty was to aid in battle. In Sparta, the government and voting was held by select elites. These elites would most likely make decisions for themselves, without considering the well-being of other citizens not wealthy enough to vote. This would be undesirable for Spartan slaves and common people as their voices are not heard, and they have no rights in their freedom to vote.
The government in Sparta followed a very different coarse than that of the Athenians. It was controlled by an oligarchy in which the power was held by a group of five men called ephors. Working below the ephors was the Council of Elders and an Assembly. Male citizens over age sixty could serve on the Council while anyone, male or female, over the age of twenty could be a member of the Assembly. Though the citizens had little say in the decisions made by the government, the system worked effectively. Over the years, the Spartan's brutal reputation in war grew so great that other nations and city-states were too frightened to attack Sparta even though the Spartan army was no larger then eight thousand men. The Spartan Constitution called for all men to begin their military education at the age of seven, where they were trained to be tough and self-sufficient. Every man in the army fought with a great deal of passion for his country. Life in Sparta may have been rough, but the rest of the Greeks envied the Spartans for their simplicity, straight forwardness, and fanatical dedication. The beliefs of Sparta were oriented around the state. The individual lived and died for the state. The combination of this philosophy, the education of Spartan males, and the discipline of their army gave the Spartans the stability needed to survive in Ancient Greece.
Athens and Sparta are the two famous city-states in Ancient Greece. The Athens was more superior then Sparta. The Athenians were stronger because they had a better geography, government, cultural achievements, and I would rather live in the Athens.
Were the people better served by the democracy in Athens or the oligarchy of Sparta?
Ancient Greece was comprised of small city-states, of which Sparta and Athens were two. Athens was renowned as a center of wisdom and learning. The people of Athens were interested in arts, music, and intellectual pursuits. Sparta, on the other hand, was recognized for its military strength. A Spartan's life was centered on the state, because he lived and died to serve the state. Although the competing city-states of Sparta and Athens were individually different as well as governmentally diverse, they both managed to become dominating powers in Ancient Greece.
Sparta was governed as an Oligarchy where a few male citizens were elected to govern the city state in an annual
Athens and Sparta were two of the most powerful and well known cities among all the Greek nations. Most would find it easier to find more similarities among these two groups of mighty people. But there are some differences between these two power houses. For instance the way that these cities were governed and their political procedures and functions were quite different from each other.
Two kings ruled Sparta together with equal powers in religious and military matters. There was a council of elders to determine judicial issues and all proposals to the citizens. Moreover, a Spartan assembly of thirty males taken from a small, elite population, ratified decisions that had already been formulated. A board of ephors, elected annually, balanced the power of kings, controlled foreign policy, presided at assembly, and guarded against rebellion by the Helots. To say that Sparta was militaristic and aristocratic was extremely accurate. Everything in society involved the military and the city-state was ruled by select members of
In Sparta there was an assembly made up of recognized free male citizens. Periokoi, Helots and Spartan men who lost their citizenship rights were not allowed to join the assembly. The Assembly decided who to elect into the Ephors and Gerousia, made legislation and decisions for war. The power of the assembly was limited to what Ephors and Gerousia would allow, they decided what decisions the assembly were allowed to make and who had the power to veto their decisions.
Each king had their separate duty, one to lead the soldiers to battle and one to govern the state itself. As the lawgiver Lycurgus came to power, he instituted a senate which he named the Council of Elders. This allowed an equal vote with the kings on matters of high importance.Good. The number of senators was made to be twenty-eight. As for the people, at age thirty, Spartan men were granted their full rights as citizens. They were eligible to vote for their leaders and their laws. The qualified citizens, known as the homoioi, were expected to participate in a general assembly to vote on legislation and electing members to the Council of Elders. Sparta thrived off of their agricultural success and their territory expansion. By capturing neighboring city-states, they were able to turn those captured into slaves and produce crops from their rich soil. Unlike Athens, the Spartans looked down upon the idea of trade because the thought of new ideas entering Sparta was a fear for
The ancient civilization of Greece contained many different city-states; two of these city-states were Sparta and Athens. Sparta and Athens were different in their values, politics, and societies. Sparta was focused on their military, discipline, and to have a strong state. Athens was a democratic state that was peaceful and where women were open to culture and democracy. How do these two city-states differ?