preview

Comparison Of The Rue Morgue And The Black Cat

Decent Essays

It may seem that Edgar Allan Poe’s stories have no correlation to one another, such as The Black Cat and The Murders in the Rue Morgue, after all one is the telling of a madman’s confession and the other a detective story. Although at first glance there seems to be no particular similarities, I hope to convey otherwise. In The Black Cat there is a lot of talk about animals, demonstrating the narrator’s great love for them, never expecting that death would be brought from this great love. Overtime the narrator experienced some changes. He became an alcoholic altering his behavior, even his behavior towards his “favorite pet and playmate” Pluto. His actions lead to Pluto the cat being killed, and after this cats death the narrator encounters a cat very similar to his dead one. His wife grew much found of it and he realized he greatly disliked this cat. He was so enraged that one day he nearly killed the “beast.” Considering his previous …show more content…

The reason no one seems to solve the crime is because everyone is trying to look for obvious clues, rather than taking a step back and analyzing the crime scene as a whole. Which is exactly what Dupin does, from the start he observes the outside of the house deducting that someone or something must have climbed the pole next to the window. He finally comes to the conclusion that an orangutan committed the murder because of its immense strength, ability to climb, and the audible but not understandable sound the neighbors hear. The question remains how an orangutan even got to this place, and that is when Dupin comes to the conclusion that a sailor brought it with him and somehow it had escaped. Although at the beginning there seemed to be no explanation, it is clear that there is an explanation for the events that happened just as there is an explanation as to why the narrator from The Black Cat did what he

Get Access