preview

Disadvantages Of Literature-Based Reading

Satisfactory Essays

Advantages/Disadvantages
Until recently, students associated reading with answering questions on a worksheet instead of literature and this destroyed their enthusiasm and excitement for reading.
According to (Perles, 2017), some of the advantages of literature-based instruction’s focus is on authentic literature, instead of a variety of textbook excerpts and other programs. Books that teach reading are boring and do not open the student’s mind that introduce them to a new world of different cultures, stories and social structures. Another advantage to using authentic literature is it encourages students to think, increase their vocabulary, comprehension and ability to read. It also releases the teacher from structured teaching and allows him or her to coach, model and even become part of the students interaction with the literature.
Disadvantages mentioned by (Perles, 2017) based on the concerns of teachers are the need for training is necessary, it is difficult because it deviates from the previous way of teaching reading. New teachers may find it difficult (although I disagree with this because new teachers taking this class, would have an advantage over the seasoned teachers because they have experience the approach through the activities assigned). It is time consuming, but teachers have all summer long from the classroom, taking 2 weeks out of that time could be used to plan lessons and the approach to be used in the classroom. Perles, 2017, also reminds that teachers may have difficulty assessing their students progress using the literature-based approach.
The last disadvantage Perles (2017) lists in the problem of finding appropriate literature selections that give the students the skills to continue to build each year is almost impossible. Therefore, continuity will be lacking and this will prevent the students as they progress from grade to grade from growing as thinkers, writers, and readers. I am not sure that I agree with this statement because with the internet, a little research can steer us in the direction of finding appropriate literature selections that will give the students the skills needed.
Quoting from Ralph Waldo Emerson “Difficulties exist to be surmounted” As teachers, I think this

Get Access