ENRON ACCOUNTING FAILURE AND ETHICAL ISSUES
ENRON ACCOUNTING FAILURE AND ETHICAL ISSUES
Lecturer: DR SITI ZELEHA ABDUL RASHID
Prepared by: SAMIRA ALVANDI SHAHRZAD KARIMI HAMED KHAZAEI
1
ENRON ACCOUNTING FAILURE AND ETHICAL ISSUES
ENRON ACCOUNTING FAILURE AND ETHICAL ISSUES
2
ENRON ACCOUNTING FAILURE AND ETHICAL ISSUES
Table of content:
Abstract……………………………………………………………………………..…...4 1. Introduction ……………………………………………………………………..……5 2. Literature review ……………………………………………………………….….....5 2.1 Accounting failure concept:……………………………………………….…..….5 2.2 Sample of accounting failure in organization………………………………....…6 2.2 Ethical issue concept………………………………………………………….….9 3. Research methodology…………………………………………………………..…...12 4. An
…show more content…
This method has launched by Government Oversight Agency like Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) in United State for research and investigation of large public corporations. Government Oversight Agency is able to clarify the catastrophic losing and failures. Notable that much abuse and misusage can be legal. In term of privatization that is very easy for executive manager to reduce the price of company`s stock according to Information Asymmetry(Gérard Roland 2008 ) .The Executive manager can
5
ENRON ACCOUNTING FAILURE AND ETHICAL ISSUES
speed up accounting of e expected costs and postpone accounting of expected revenue as well as using off balance sheet to show the profitability of company is provisionally
negligible and poor .All accounting failure not only related to Executives or officials but also the employees and lower ranking official are responsible . Often time employees are in pressure or willingly for modify financial statement either for personal benefit or officials benefit. There are top 10 accounting problems in an organization which will be explain in later part.
2.2. Sample of accounting failure in organization:
10 popular accounting shortfalls 1. Playing with numbers: many corruptions,
In addition, associated with the misapplication of accounting methods, the financial industry has been plagued with one disaster after another involving numerous scandals from top leading American companies. Consequently, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act was passed in 2002 compromising eleven sections that are generated to insure the responsibilities of the company’s managers and executives. This act identifies criminal penalties for particular unethical practices and currently has new policies that a corporation must follow in their financial reporting. The following examples describe some of biggest accounting methods as a result of the greed and the outrage of the ethical and financial misconduct by the senior management of public corporations.
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX), also known as the Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection Act and the Auditing Accountability and Responsibility Act, was signed into law on July 30, 2002, by President George W. Bush as a direct response to the corporate financial scandals of Enron, WorldCom, and Tyco International (Arens & Elders, 2006; King & Case, 2014;Rezaee & Crumbley, 2007). Fraudulent financial activities and substantial audit failures like those of Arthur Andersen and Ernst and Young had destroyed public trust and investor confidence in the accounting profession. The debilitating consequences of these perpetrators and their crimes summoned a massive effort by the government and the accounting profession to fight all forms of corruption through regulatory, legal, auditing, and accounting changes.
Finally, the paper highlights the significance of the research to the accounting practice and future research studies before describing the research’s limitations and the implications on author’s conclusion.
In the Enron case, The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Congress conducted an investigation into Enron's collapse. The authorities re-examined the roles of corporate watchdogs, including corporate boards of directors, auditors, investment banks, credit rating agencies and lawyers. It could be that the watchdogs had too tight relations with the company's executives. That is why no one questioned the Enron's aggressive accounting strategies. To prevent such collapses, someone needs to look into the possible conflict of interest. The dilemma is that auditors should perform in the interests of the investors, but they are paid by the audited company, which makes it more difficult for them to exercise tough decisions. The auditors should not perform some particular consulting services for the firms that they audit. Another belief is that there should be more severe consequences for those committing financial crimes and causing fall of the companies.
In this incident, the chairman of one of India’s largest technology company, Ramalingam Raju, the person who has sought to use technology to improve life in rural India said that he concocted important financial results, including a cash balance of more than 1 billion dollars. Analysts in India have termed the Satyam scandal India's own Enron scandal. Some social commentators see it more as a part of a broader problem relating to India's caste-based, family-owned corporate environment. This Scandal is obviously a major blow to the reputation of the IT outsourcing industry in India, and reveals some of the challenges of due diligence in such relationships.
As with much of Enron, their outward appearance did not match what was really going on inside the company. Enron ended up cultivating their own demise for bankruptcy by how they ran their company. This corrupt corporate culture was a place whose employees threw ethical responsibility to the wind if it meant financial gain. At Enron, the employees were motivated by a very “cut-throat” culture. If an employee didn’t perform well enough, they would simply be replaced by someone who could. “The company’s culture had profound effects on the ethics of its employees” (Sims, pg.243). Like a parent to their children, when the executives of a company pursue unethical financial means, it sets a certain tone for their employees and even the market of the company. As mentioned before, Enron had a very “cut-throat” attitude in regards to their employees. This also became one Enron’s main ethical falling points. According to the class text, “employees were rated every six months, with those ranked in the bottom 20 percent forced to leave” (Ferrell, 2017, pg. 287). This system which pits employees against each other rather than having them work together will create a workplace of dishonesty and a recipe of disaster for the company. This coupled with the objective of financial growth, creates a very dim opportunity for any ethical culture. “The entire cultural framework of Enron not only allowed unethical behavior to flourish,
In October 2001, Enron Corporation which was one of the world major energy, commodities and service companies with claimed revenues of nearly 111 billion dollars during 2000 collapsed under the weight of massive fraud in that it has become largest bankruptcy recognition in the US economy. Enron’s earning report was extremely skewed that losses were not represented in their entirety, prompting more and more wishing to participate in what seemed like a profitable company. After collapse of Enron, Auditor independence has become a social issue that weather auditor has to be independent or not. In addition, while auditing must consider matters objectively with dispassion, there were still doubts whether it implemented well. Further, there has been much speculation about the need for the mandatory rotation of auditors or audit firm rotation to warn false accounting between audit firm and client. By examining Enron case, this essay will discuss about advantages and drawbacks of the mandatory rotation of
Ethical behavior is behavior that a person considers to be appropriate. A person’s moral principals are shaped from birth, and developed overtime throughout the person’s life. There are many factors that can influence what a person believes whats is right, or what is wrong. Some factors are a person’s family, religious beliefs, culture, and experiences. In business it is of great importance for an employee to understand how to act ethically to prevent a company from being sued, and receiving criticism from the public while bringing in profits for the company. (Mallor, Barnes, Bowers, & Langvardt, 2010) Business ethics is when ethical behavior is applied in an business environment, or by a business. There are many
Regulation is an important way to enforce ethic and accountability of business. Through the unit, we can see there are some argument against regulatory. Under the free market approach, even without regulation there are private economic-based incentives for the business to provide credible info to outside parties, to avoid an increase in cost of operations. When there is a free market, the theory of market for managers and market for corporate takeovers assume managers’ previous performance will impact on how much remuneration they command in future, or whether they would be replaced by an existing management team, they will be encouraged to adopt strategies to maximise the value of their organization. The assumption is based on the agency theory, which focuses on the self-interest motivation. However, self-interest may create lots of issues as we discussed earlier, holds that regulation
Enron’s ride is quite a phenomenon: from a regional gas pipeline trader to the largest energy trader in the world, and then back down the hill into bankruptcy and disgrace. As a matter of fact, it took Enron 16 years to go from about $10 billion of assets to $65 billion of assets, and 24 days to go bankruptcy. Enron is also one of the most celebrated business ethics cases in the century. There are so many things that went wrong within the organization, from all personal (prescriptive and psychological approaches), managerial (group norms, reward system, etc.), and organizational (world-class culture) perspectives. This paper will focus on the business ethics issues at Enron that were raised from the documentation Enron: The Smartest Guys
Being the president of a company would render many challenges, including the responsibility for establishing the values for the organization. Incorporating life experiences would be a great determinate in establishing such values, in addition to considering what has been witnessed in the past concerning the success and downfall of other organizations, such as the unethical decisions of the organizational leaders of Enron, realizing that Enron had a written policy, however choosing to value financial greed (Hansen, Alge, Brown, Jackson, & Dunford, 2013). Therefore, I would set expectations high, developing a code of conduct, along with the expected values of the company, which would include the value of integrity. By making it known on the front end that honesty is the best policy, in addition to living the example, employees will demonstrate trust and respect, therefore developing a strong work relationship.
Q 1: Evaluate Enron profit and cash flow performance during the period 1998 – 2000?
Question 1 Summarize 1 one page how you would explain Enron’s ethical meltdown: Enron was an energy company founded by Kenneth Lay in 1985 through a merger of vast networks of natural gas lines. Enron specialized in wholesale, natural gas, and electricity, and made its money as a wholesaler between suppliers and customers rather than actually owning any. Enron in fact didn’t own any assets, which made their accounting procedures very unusual. The lack of accounting transparency at Enron allowed the company’s managers to make Enron’s financial performance better than it actually was. The organizational culture at Enron was to blame for it’s ethical meltdown. Enron’s accounting scheme slowly began to erode its ethical practices, which soon led the culture of Enron to become a more aggressive and misleading business practice. Enron reported profits from joint partnerships that were not yet attained in order to keep stock prices up (or make wall street happy). As this was happening employees began to notice the ethics in senior management (leadership) deteriorating, and soon after they to would follow in their footsteps. Senior management thought they were saving their company from financial ruin and though lying was ok if it meant saving the company. Investors would surely sell their stocks if they really knew the situation the
There was a vast number of ethical issues raised in the movie “Enron-the Smartest Guys in the Room” but the four I am going to focus on are listed below. Art Anderson, Ken Lay and all of the other executives did a number of unethical things which ultimately brought down Enron and affected thousands of employees and their futures. The bottom line was that each and every one of them acted out of greed for the almighty dollar.
Ethics is something that is very important to have especially in the business world. Ethics is the unwritten laws or rules defined by human nature; ethics is something people encounter as a child learning the differences between right and wrong. In 2001, Enron was the fifth largest company on the Fortune 500. Enron was also the market leader in energy production, distribution, and trading. However, Enron's unethical accounting practices have left the company in joint chapter 11 bankruptcy. This bankruptcy has caused many problems among many individuals. Enron's employees and retirees are suffering because of the bankruptcy. Wall Street and investors have taken a major downturn do to the company's unethical practices. Enron's competitors