preview

Essay On Gatsby And Janie

Decent Essays

Social Mobility For Gatsby vs Janie Upon first glance, Gatsby from Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, and Janie from Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God seem very different. Gatsby-- a wealthy white man-- seemingly has all the ability in the world to gain money and status. Whereas Janie appears to have very little social mobility, as she is a black woman living in the South. However, upon closer inspection it is clear that they have similar hopes and dreams, and that within their communities, their ability to move up is different than how it appears. Janie can easily move up since her money and light skin is all she needs to gain respect, and Gatsby struggles to really gain status since he faces the barrier of being new money vs old …show more content…

They both experience a feeling of separation from their communities, due to envy in Janie’s case, and for Gatsby a social hierarchy. Gatsby is compelled to move up and achieve his dreams, even though he is judged for how he does it, “ Certainly not for a common swindler who’d have to steal the ring he put on her finger,”(Fitzgerald, pg 140). Janie, however, is pressured to pick between survival through wealth, or true happiness. She has a lot more pressure to move up, from her family, and because she has light skin and is seen as a rare beauty. It is almost seen as a crime for her not to try and gain status and not separate herself: “A can’t stand em mahself. ‘Nother thing, I hates tuh see folks lak me and you mixed up wid’ em. Us oughta class off,”(Hurston, pg 141). On the other hand, Gatsby’s attempts to become financially and socially equal to his neighbors are frowned upon and seen as misguided and disrespectful. They are both judged for pursuing their happiness, in opposite ways. Though they come from very different worlds, Janie and Gatsby both stand out as wealthy. They have been lucky enough to move up to this position of wealth while others are stuck in poverty. Janie especially has a comfortable lifestyle, which though it is humble, is the envy of others. Gatsby seems to have immeasurable wealth, but he is still often looked down upon and judged, facing a social

Get Access