preview

Evaluation Of The Participant Recruitment Stage

Good Essays

Method

With the limitations within the methodology, it will be difficult to replicate this study. These limitations which will be discussed are as follows; no mention of the participant recruitment stage, if it was a ‘blind’ research, ethical considerations, no evidence of the OPTIC schedule, how time was kept and how the scoring was done for pupils.

The researchers state that the design of their research is observational in primary and secondary schools but they fail to state why this method was chosen. There were also no variables or conditions stated which does not let the reader know if anything is controlled in the study. They also failed to mention the aim of the study which does not give the reader a direction in which the observations would go.

The researchers gave information about the teachers who were used in the study but did not mention anything about the students who were present in the classes. From the primary schools, it can be seen that there were 22 female teachers and 10 male teachers, whilst from secondary schools, there were 17 female teachers and 21 male teachers. Though they have given these details, how the participants were recruited was not listed. This is a fundamental flaw as it would have given more information as to why the sample was so small. In addition, it then does not notify the readers whether there was a random allocation. Had teachers been randomly allocated to classes, it could be assumed that there would have been biasing the

Get Access