preview

Fair And Foul Is Fair In 'Much Ado About Nothing'

Decent Essays

Tony Li
Ms. Moffat
ENG3U6-01
Nov. 12, 2014
Love Me or Love Me Not?

At first glance, the quote “Fair is foul and foul is fair?” just seems like another one of the many senseless riddles uttered by the witches in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth. But like everything else said by the witches, the quote begins to reveal its meaning as the play progresses. As Macbeth seeks to fulfill the witches’ prophecy to become king, he gets involved in an endless cycle of murders and quickly realizes that he no longer desired becoming king. The theme of deception shown by the quote “Fair is foul and foul is fair” can be applied to many of Shakespeare’s other works as well. In Much Ado About Nothing, there are two main couples, Hero and Claudio, and Beatrice and …show more content…

Although the love between Claudio and Hero is much more pronounced, there is strong evidence in the play to suggest that the love between Beatrice and Benedick is more genuine, despite how much they insult each other.

While Claudio and Hero appear to be passionate lovers, Claudio and Hero’s façade of love conceals foul undercurrents in their relationship. There’s no denying that they are the couple more voluble about their love, especially Claudio, but there’s evidence that their feeling for each other are shallow and insincere. Claudio falls for Hero and declares his love for her the very first time that he meets her and asks her to marry him after only a few encounters. He does not give …show more content…

While Beatrice and Benedick are able to reconcile their relationship, the foul distrust between Hero and Claudio tears them asunder. After Beatrice asks Benedick to “Kill Claudio” (4.1.303), he faces a difficult choice between betraying Beatrice or Claudio. Despite Claudio being one of his best friends, Benedick shows his unwavering loyalty to Beatrice by accepting her request. Claudio, on the other hand, seems to have a distrust of Hero. Don John is easily able to cast doubts about Hero’s loyalty to him with his rumours. Claudio shows doubt in Hero’s loyalty to him when he says the line “May this be so?”(3.2.110), even when Don Pedro is skeptical of the information and states “I will not think it.” (3.2.111). In fact, Claudio shows that he even plans to dishonour Hero when he swears “If I see anything tonight why I should not marry her, tomorrow in the congregation, where I should wed, there will I shame her.”(3.3.116-118). From Claudio’s actions, we can see that Claudio has sincere doubts about Hero’s faith to him. He has nothing to gain from publicly humiliating Hero, so it seems to be an act of revenge instead. This is clearly not the basis for an enduring and loving relationship between Hero and Claudio. Had Don John’s evil plot not been discovered, Hero and Claudio may well have continued drifting apart and perhaps even turned

Get Access