preview

Film Analysis: A Streetcar Named Desire

Better Essays

Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire, and Elia Kazan’s film adaptation of the play, are both perceived in different ways by the audience. Though Tennessee Williams advocated his visions for the film adaptation, Elia Kazan interprets this in his own way, and this is reflected in the choices made by his actors in their interpretation of their characters. Kazan and Brando’s choices emphasise Stanley Kowalski’s masculinity and downplay his aggression, and this unbalances the tension Williams envisaged between the “ravishment of the tender the sensitive, the delicate, by the savage and brutal forces of modern society”. Though, Williams’ idea of the decaying old world and the rising new world is evidently publicized in both.
Through Tennessee …show more content…

Williams depicts in his play the capacity of human nature for brutality and deceit; no matter how structured or “civilised” society is, all people will rely on their animal instincts to dominate and deceive. With this as the central motif, Kazan and his actors interpret A Streetcar Named Desire. Williams’s visions were depicted in Kazan’s ideas for the adaptation, though Kazan did not express these ideas of brutality and deceit as strongly as William’s did in his play, rather Kazan downplayed the …show more content…

Stella: What? Stanley: Meat!
[He heaves the package at her. She cries out in protest but manages to catch it: then she laughs breathlessly, her husband and his companion have already started back around the corner] (Scene 1 pg 116)
Williams depicts Stanley receiving his wife's fondness with "lordly composure"; insinuating that Stanley believes that he automatically deserves his wife's respect and devotion without having to work for it in any way because he is a man; he believes that she should have these feelings towards him automatically. The statement:
"Be comfortable is my motto," (129, scene 1)
It is not a motto he actually employs towards the remaining characters; thinking only of himself, he does not care if anyone else is "comfortable". For Stanley to feel comfortable he must be in control, this is revealed in scene three, when Stella tries to throw out his friends, as Stanley is too drunk and rowdy. The result of Stella asserting some dominance, Stanley abuses her, to reassert his own ascendency, and beats out the dominance Stella displayed. Showing how clear the theme of brutality and savagery over the tender and delicate

Get Access