preview

Essay on Four Eras of Writing

Decent Essays

History has evolved over the last two centuries. In the introduction to Interpretations of American History edited by Francis G. Couvares, et al., he states that the transition of the way history was interpreted has only “linked the past more strongly to the present” (Couvares 1). Before, historians –mostly white male- used to report only about “male” topics but since then, different issues have transformed the way history used to be. Over the last 400 years, the four different stages that have reshaped the writing of American history have been the providential, the rationalist, the nationalist, and the professional. Late- nineteenth-century historians, usually called “historicists” or “positivists” believed that history was like science …show more content…

Most historians during this time were wealthy and with a high position in society, hence the style of their writing. Because of the way they thought of themselves, their history explained how the "enlightened" world was a success because of men like them. According to Couvares, Jefferson's Notes on the State of Virginia very much sums up the thought of the rationalists where they were the ones who achieved greatness, it wasn't God driven. However, the rationalists were not that far off from the providential it's because their story "still pointed upward" (Couvares 6). As the nineteenth century went on, historians started to see "America as the triumph of Anglo-Saxon people over inferior races" (Couvares 6). They thought that because America had overcome other "inferior" races that they were better. Couvares explains how Bancroft organized America's history around three themes: "progress, liberty, and Anglo-Saxon destiny" (Couvares 6). This is where the third stage comes in. Their idea that the Teutonic people were supposed to spread "freedom across the globe" was the start to their sense of pride, love, and nationalism. Not only were men, but also female historians hooked on this idea. Helen Hunt Jackson wrote about white-Indian relations, which at the time was a big obstacle to jump; while at the same time anthropologists beginning to study these relationships. Around the 1870s, though, Bancroft seemed like

Get Access