preview

Hamlet Socratic Circle Essay

Decent Essays

Hamlet Socratic Circle

1. Did Hamlet really go crazy? How does this connect to his wavering between action and inaction? Why doesn’t Hamlet just kill Claudius? Is he a just man who needs assurance beyond a doubt of Claudius’ guilt? Is he unable to take action because the opportunity never presents itself? Is he simply a coward? What are Hamlet’s true motivations for even pursuing the murder of Claudius? Is it Fear? Revenge? Love? Loyalty/Obligation?
No, Hamlet did not really go crazy
From the very beginning of the play, Hamlet retains his sanity, but at times he must exhibit insanity in order to accomplish his proclaimed duty
In the instances when he is alone or with Horatio, he acts civilized and sane
Hamlet vows to “put an antic …show more content…

2. What is the role of both Laertes and Fortinbras in the play?
Laertes and Fortinbras are parallel characters to Hamlet and provide pivotal points that are used to compare the actions and emotions of Hamlet
They are all placed in similar circumstances, to avenge their father’s deaths
The way each of them come to terms with their grief and how they rise to the call of vengeance is one of the main contrasts between the three
Hamlet and Laertes
Similarities
They both love Ophelia. Hamlet is a scholar at Wittenberg and Laertes at France. Both are admired for their swordsmanship. Both men loved and respected their fathers.
Differences
Laertes response to the death of his father is immediate. He is publicly angry and lead a public riot. His actions are rash, being based on his anger. He is not concerned with punishment.
Hamlet is very private with his grief. His mourning for his father is long and drawn out. He mulls over how he is going to act and defers action until a perfect moment.
Perpetual contemplation vs. acting on impulsion and without reason
Hamlet and Fortinbras
Fortinbras’s action to avenge his father’s death was carefully analyzed and his plan executed. He acts upon reason and not emotion.
Laertes is the extreme irrational while Fortinbras represent the logical more thoughtful man of action. Hamlet lies in the middle of this spectrum.

3. Describe Hamlet’s relationship with Ophelia. Did Hamlet really love Ophelia? Is he to blame in her

Get Access