preview

Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird and Truman Capote's A Christmas Memory

Good Essays

Harper Lee and Truman Capote, two of the greatest 20th century authors, were once prodigious best friends. And best friends share everything; their thoughts, their dreams, but most importantly, their ideas. So could it be possible that Capote, a prolific writer, could have played a role in writing Lee’s esteemed novel, To Kill a Mockingbird? Doubtful. Through comparisons of Lee’s only work to Capote’s “A Christmas Memory” it can be seen that despite similarities, these friends’ works differ too greatly in the way they set the tone, emphasize their themes, and utilize imagery for them to have worked together on her novel.
The first area, where Capote and Lee vary, is their use of style to create tone. Due to two extremely diverse plotlines, …show more content…

/‘Atticus?’ said Jem. /‘Yes?’ /‘Nothin’’” (p.97). This is the scene where the children learn their father, whom they believe to have no physical skills, is the best shot in town after shooting a rabid dog. There is no direct interpretation from the narrator leaving readers with only the characters’ dialogue to ponder. The effect is a speechless tone. While one author interacts with the text as the author, setting up each scene and action, the other only interacts as a character and this can be directly attributed to which tense they write. So despite similar overlying tones and point of views, Capote and Lee diverge immediately in style.
As most authors do, both Lee and Capote wound similar themes and subthemes throughout their pieces, yet use completely different techniques to isolate these themes. In To Kill a Mockingbird, the theme is stated multiple times, interpreted by every character, and then confirmed by the narrator. Atticus tells Scout “You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view…” (p.30) stating the theme directly. 200 pages later, the narrator, Scout realizes that her father was right as she views the neighborhood in a perspective she was too afraid to approach before. In between, the idea of prejudging a person is toiled with in every struggle and outburst. The theme, first introduced in a simple conflict, is reemphasized at the very end, affirming the importance of never enforcing a stereotype

Get Access