preview

Hospital Admissions

Good Essays

Hospital admissions account for the largest component of health care expenditures (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (2011). In the past several decades, the critical decisions for determining need for hospitalization have been increasingly made by emergency medicine (EM) physicians (Schuur & Venkatesh, 2012). In view of the impact of hospital admissions, both hospitals and physicians are increasingly encouraged to find alternatives that are less costly. Nevertheless, perhaps wary that non-clinical factors may adversely influence EM physician decisions, in October 2015, the American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) published a policy statement regarding Emergency Physician Rights and Responsibilities. An important stated …show more content…

In adults, Calder, et al. (2013) reported experienced ED physicians relied six-fold on clinical acumen rather than evidenced-based guidelines in making critical decisions (87.6% vs 12.4%). Similar phenomena have been found in emergency care of children. Bourgeois, Monuteaux, Stack, & Neuman (2014) reported a greater than threefold variation in severity adjusted admission rates for common pediatric conditions across 35 US tertiary children’s hospitals participating in the Pediatric Health Information System (PHIS) database. Although local practices and hospital-level factors partly explain this variation, they concluded that there was a need for a greater focus on the standardization of decisions regarding admission. Importantly, they were unable to further examine factors that might contribute to variation in admission rates, including hospital- and physician-related characteristics because these were not consistently available in the data base. Using the same data base, Kharbanda, et al. (2013) sampled >250,000 visits to 21 children’s hospital emergency departments (ED) and found significant variation in quality measures for patients with three common illnesses (febrile seizures, asthma, gastroenteritis). Importantly, higher costs were not associated with …show more content…

After adjusting for patient and clinical characteristics, the hospital-level admission rate varied from 27% to 41% and the physician level, admission rates varied from 21% to 49% (Abualenain, et al., 2013). Similarly, Gutterman, J.J., Lundberg, S.R., Scheib, G.P., Richman, M.J., Wang, C-J., & Talan, D.A. (2016) found highly variable admission rates (15.2-32%). Although these correlated to Medicaid denied payment day rates, the variance was unexplained by known confounding clinical variables and unrelated to the quality of care. Interestingly, attending physician estimates of their admission rate ranged from 7-33% with 71% overestimating and 24 % under estimating their own admission rate and there was no significant correlation between actual and self-described admission

Get Access