preview

Is Macbeth A Tragic Hero?

Decent Essays

People always ask, “What is a tragic hero?” The question that should be asked is, “Who is more of a tragic hero, Macbeth or Hamlet?” Macbeth is the more tragic hero when compared to Hamlet because Hamlet had nothing to lose the whole time. The three things that make Macbeth a more a lamentable legend than Hamlet is his appalling blemish of being presumptuous, being vanquished toward the end and decapitated by Macduff and losing the greater part of his Fortune, and ultimately his acknowledgment of his results of his executing Macduff's family toward the end of the play. These are the reasons that will be used to make evident why Macbeth is more of a tragic hero than Hamlet. Furthermore, the number one thing that shows Macbeth as a more tragic hero is his overconfident trait. In an article by Paul Case says, “A tragic hero is described as a noble character you can empathize with, and whose flaw leads to his demise.” Macbeth is a tragic hero because he was born of a noble birth, as well as Hamlet. Also Macbeth has that tragic flaw of being overconfident that leads to his demise while Hamlet couldn’t decide if he should kill his father's murderer. In the play Macbeth, Macbeth states, “Let them fall all Till Birnam wood remove to Dunsinane, I cannot taint with fear.”(Shakespeare, Macbeth 3.5.39) Macbeth is stating that he couldn't care less if the greater part of his men abandon him and is demonstrating to the readers that when he is pompous he settles on hurried choices that are exceptionally rash that end up gnawing him in the butt. This makes Macbeth the tragic hero because Macbeth is being the only one fighting while his men are running away like cowards leaving him to fend for himself. Albeit one may contend that Hamlet additionally had a sad blemish of being uncertain which is expressed in the play Hamlet, “Contagion to this world. Now could I drink hot blood And do such bitter business as the day Would quake to look on. Soft, now to my mother.”(Shakespeare, Hamlet, 5.2.45) Hamlet is by and by going to slaughter his dad's killer, however then chooses, he needs to converse with his mother demonstrating to us that he is too ambivalent to execute Claudius. This makes Macbeth look more of a tragic hero because

Get Access