preview

Killing In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men

Decent Essays

Is killing justified if it is done out of mercy? John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men is centered around this age old debate, specifically through the quote “Sometimes in life we’re forced to make decisions and take actions we don’t agree with, but are necessary.” This is first demonstrated by Slim after his dog had a large litter of puppies. He realized that the mother couldn’t provide for that many, so he “drowned four of ‘em right off”. If he hadn’t, some of the pups would have died of starvation. His choice saved them from a painfully slow death. However, like many momentous decisions, Slim’s actions were not without consequence. Without basis, the act of murdering defenseless animals sounds completely evil, which Slim surely realized. A decision like his would leave any sane person with a heavy heart, a feeling that a person like Slim would keep to himself. …show more content…

Carlson was finally fed up with the smell of the dog and argued that it should be put down, offering to do it himself. Candy helplessly looked to the faces of the other men, hoping that they would side with him, but no one else seemed to care either way. Eventually, Candy allowed Carlson to do the job, if only so that he didn’t appear weak in front of the workers. This circumstance differed from Slim’s as it was not a necessity for the dog to be killed, though Carlson managed to trick Candy into thinking otherwise. Carlson pressured him into believing that the dog needed to be taken care of because it was in pain, but he was just doing it for his own cold, selfish reasons. Candy didn’t realize this until it was too late. He should have been the one to put his dog down, if

Get Access