preview

Lyndal Roper's Persecution Summary

Decent Essays

Historians of European witchcraft can all agree that there was definitely a period of time where people were accused, tried, and executed for witchcraft. They cannot agree on the ‘whys’. Why did it happen, why did the demographics of the accused change from place to place, why did it end? As a result there has been much work on the subject, all with vastly different conclusions. For Lyndal Roper, some of those ‘whys’ are fertility and fear. More specifically, fear of losing it. Roper describes witchcraft as “an intensely physical experience” (Roper, 9). The effect the witches ad on their surrounding involved the physical world, but mostly the vitality and fertility of it. Babies were harmed, breast-milk dried, people were made to become impotent …show more content…

The first parts finds Roper examining early modern Germany and its state of affairs. We learn that demographically, culturally, and religiously the country was highly divided, but were somehow able to unified in one idea: “witch-hunters of the baroque saw themselves as soldiers, sworn to fight the Devil and his minions, and as Christians entrusted with the duty of saving witches’ souls” (Roper, 43). This is how Roper answers the question posed as to why Germany held such a high and violent concentration of witch persecutions. This leads into the second, which explores the interrogations. Historians are all puzzled by the fact that interrogators required elaborate details before they could believe a witch’s confession, but still know that she was guilty of whatever crimes she was accused of. As a result of this heavy torture was employed until they got the answers they wanted which had to be detailed, convincing, and different from any other witch’s confession. It is very puzzling. Roper, consequently, does not see the confessions as an accurate historical source of actual happenings, due to the psychological and physical torture used to gain them in addition to them being drenched in demonology, but as accurate historical sources in grasping what the beliefs of the interrogators and society were, more specifically what they

Get Access