preview

Madness, Madness And Philosophy, By Herman Melville

Better Essays

Every literary text continues to communicate with madness. Through the use of Shoshanna Felman’s “Madness and Philosophy,” we will explore the nature of madness as seen in Herman Melville’s short story “Bartleby the Scrivener.” Felman argues that madness arises when there is conflict of the thought. She says:
Reason and madness are inextricably linked; madness is essentially a phenomenon of thought, of thought which claims to denounce, in another’s thought, the other of thought: that which thought is not. Madness can only occur within a world of conflict, within a conflict of thoughts. The question of madness is nothing less than the question of thought itself: the question of madness, in other words, is that which turns the essence of thought, precisely into a question.
To further understand this claim, we must understand what Felman means by “madness.” “Madness” could mean one of three things: First, madness is literal in that a psychological affliction is expressed physically; second, madness could be a state of mind where thoughts are cloudy and the thought process is ridden with external factors that are uncontrolled by a person; and third, madness is a mixture of the afore mentioned cases. Consequently, to understand madness, we must understand reason. Reason, the entity that drives all human interactions, has created madness by radically dividing reason and non-reason and qualifying anything that is not reason to be madness. Ironically however, it is the same

Get Access