preview

Mark Twain's Assessment Of James Fennimore Cooper

Decent Essays

Mark Twain’s assessment of James Fennimore Cooper’s “literary offenses” is an outrageous attack on one of the most proven of early 19th century authors. If one is to believe it satire, as has often been asserted, then why choose Cooper at all? Surely there were more fitting Romantic authors for Mark Twain to “pick on.” If this is, indeed, a real attack against the author, then it is incorrect and fallacious. Twain condescending and malicious tone discredits his own arguments as he proceeds to make wild exaggerations, as well as attack the word usage of Cooper. In Twain’s very first line and again near the end, he discredits the arguments he intends to make. In his criticism of Cooper, however, he also takes a shot at professor’s Lounsbury …show more content…

His first method was by declaring that his word usage, or lack thereof, showed a “high talent for inaccurate observation” (Twain). Twain provides an example for this accusation by relating the story of the shooting match in The Pathfinder. While Twain does find several issues with the scene, it starts with him mentioning how important it is to know what color the head of the nail was painted. Twain, in this way, also insults the audience, who he apparently believes are not smart or imaginative enough to use their own mind’s eye. His second attack of word usage on Cooper begins with “Cooper's word-sense was singularly dull” (Twain), comparing Cooper’s language to a flat or sharp pitched singer. He criticizes words used for the words he, himself, would have chosen, such as "mortified" for "disappointed,” "rebuked" for "subdued,” and "distrusted" for "suspicious.” Of course, to distrust someone is not necessarily the same as being suspicious of them, and to be mortified is a much more intense emotion than disappointed. Who is to say if the words Cooper chose were not the correct ones? Twain, in his eighteen rules, even stated, “Use the right word, not its second cousin.” And, again, technically, should the “right word” not have been the “correct” one? Twain himself falls prey to his own criticism in this

Get Access