preview

Mens Re An Actus Reus

Good Essays

Mens rea is a necessary element, alongside an actus reus, in order for a person to be convicted in the majority of crimes. It is required to prove the mens rea in every common law and statutory offence making it a significant part of any case which enters the courtroom. There are two common forms of mens rea; intention, wicked recklessness and negligence. Both of these forms, if proven, constitute as a sufficient mens rea to be criminally liable. Intention – The highest form of mens rea- is more than simple contemplation and is when one person purposely causes harm to another individual. The case of Cunliffe v. Goodman involved a landlord who was intending to pull down a building on the termination of the lease. At the end of the lease, the premises was in bad repair and the landlord requested action to be taken on the tenant for the damage. However, the tenant was under the impression that the building was being demolished and refused to pay for any disrepair. It was found that the tenant was ‘protected from liability to pay damages’ . Wicked recklessness – the ‘total indifference to and disregard for the safety of the public’ In the case of McDowall v. HM Advocate, a man was charged with culpable homicide for driving recklessly. The presiding judge stated that the man had ‘utter disregard for the victims and the fact that he drove with the bonnet in an upright position are factors that the jury were entitled to take into account’ when considering his state of mind at

Get Access