preview

Pope Pius XII: Hitler's Actions During The Holocaust

Better Essays

For decades a debate has rampaged on whether Pope Pius XII was Hitler’s Pope or amiable Supreme Pontiff regarding his actions during the Holocaust, one cartoonist, entitled Steve Greenberg, illustrated his judgements on the dispute. Published in the Jewish Journal of Greater Los Angeles, Greenberg created a piece entitled “Pope Pius” [Figure 1] which refers to the way that Pius XII handled the Holocaust and incorporates the recent occurrence of Pope Benedict XVI pushing Pius for canonization. The image depicts Pius standing idle with flames blazing behind him and Jew’s hands reaching for aid at the bottom of the fire near Pius, all with Nazi flags elevated above the other components of the cartoon; next to Pius stands Pope Benedict, the only …show more content…

With reference to the situation that the cartoon is about, the evil that is succeeding is the Nazi Party, symbolized by the swastika flag, and this evil is triumphing due to the lack of action from the “good” Pius XII. A quick glance at this cartoon could result in a viewer misreading the cartoon, perceiving the author’s message as Pius XII sealing the fate of the persecuted Jews, but a closer analysis into the leading quotation refutes this judgment. This hasty opinion of Pius XII being drawn basically as Hitler’s Pope by ignoring the Jew’s hands reaching for assistance, allowing the Nazi flags to wave, and looking content with the fire burning in the background could lead to the incorrect interpretation of Greenberg’s intent with this piece. By leading with a quotation that refers to Pius as a good man that did nothing in relation to the Holocaust, Greenberg is not calling Pius XII out for single-handedly sealing the fate of the Jews, but instead presenting the viewpoint that Pius stood idle while the Holocaust occurred; as deduced from the quotation the cartoon reads as Pius not doing enough to save the Jews, not the Pope …show more content…

This Lilliputian addition to this work signifies that Greenberg wanted the viewer to know that those up-reaching hands were Jews, not any supplementary tyrannized group. Accordingly, these hands symbolize the Jewish population which is a vital component of the cartoonist’s message. If left unlabeled those hands could just be symbolizing the persecuted groups in general, like the Poles and disabled, but by classifying the victims Greenberg is specifically referencing how the Jews were ignored by Pope Pius. This labeling is noteworthy to the entire cartoon because it switches the main message from Pope Pius doing nothing to aid the Holocaust victims to him not assisting the Jews. By doing this Greenberg also creates a juxtaposition between the Catholicism of the Pope and the Judaism of the portrayed victims, consequently helping to clearly define the key characters or groups in this artwork. So, the labeling of the Star of David visually isolates the Jews as the persecuted group in question, making it apparent that Greenberg is calling Pope Pius out for not helping the Jews

Get Access