preview

Reality In 'New People's And New Societies'

Decent Essays

As we know, the United States was a British colony and there were native American live here before; after the Europeans settled America, a new group of Americans was created. But what is truly American? And what was their real life like after they came here. The ideal of America was a heaven for the people who wanted to get a new life that is happy and free. But there is always a gap between the ideal and the reality; the reality will never be as good as the ideal and people would always have opinions towards the society and the government. In "New People's and New Societies” by Colin G. Calloway, Calloway tells the story of how the Europeans took the Indian land and built a new America, and how they got advantages from the Indian culture …show more content…

In “Letter to His Parents” by Richard Frethorne, Richard shows his daily life in America is not wonder like they imagine before. Richard said: “…but I’m not half a quarter so strong as I was in England, and all is for want of victuals, for I doe protest unto you, that I have eaten more in a day at home than I have allowed me here for a week…” and this is a directly hint of the truth when they come to America. Secondly, Ruth Rosen said in "The War to Control the Past", "Some would like to erase our country's crimes and tell a story of triumphant and virtuous democracy. Others would like to evoke a history of victimization”. Rosen suggests a different story than that which Calloway and Crevecoeur alone tell. Rosen talks about an editor and publisher L.Frank Baum, who called for "total annihilation" of native Americans. He said, “in order to protect our civilization, wipe out these untamed and untamable creatures from the face of the earth". And he is not the only one who hated or discriminated against the native American and tried to erase the history of their subjection to protect what they see as their own country. Baum loathed native American, but according to Rosen he created a world "as diverse and complex as the nation in which he lived," and he wanted children to relish the world he

Get Access