preview

Rhetorical Analysis Of 'Vengeance Is Ours' By Jared Diamond

Decent Essays

In his New Yorker article “Vengeance Is Ours,” Jared Diamond makes the claim that revenge is a universal feeling and that state governments alienate us from satisfactory feelings derived from revenge. Through two narratives Diamond exhibits the satisfaction derived from revenge, as well as the dismay when revenge is not achieved. He first examines the story of Daniel Wemp who, after the murder of his uncle at the hands of a man named Isum, goes on a quest to avenge him and feels the euphoria of revenge. It took Daniel three years, twenty nine other murders, and three hundred pig sacrifices to achieve this, but when he finally heard that Isum was dead he felt “as if I am developing wings” and as if he was “about to fly off”(7). To do contrast …show more content…

There is a wealth of psychological research into the effects of emotional suppression with most studies reaching the same conclusion that Gross et. al uncovered: suppression of negative emotions leads a person to consistently perceive all events as more negative and depressing. Diamond is unequivocally correct that negative emotions need to be acknowledged, but his implicit advice is that after acknowledgment, one should just suppress those feelings as there is no lawful outlet for him. The fundamental misstep of his argument is his dichotomization of courses of actions to remedy negative feelings; either someone takes revenge or does not take revenge, there is no other way for them to quell negative feelings. Diamond also does not discuss the negative aspects of revenge, especially the perpetuation of the cycle of violence. While, according to psychology professor Michael McCullough, revenge is like an unfulfilled craving, it only begets more revenge. Continuing the cycle of revenge does not help anyone, as Bud Welch, father of one of the 168 people killed at the Oklahoma Federal Building bombing, realized. Revenge only keeps “the circle of violence going. Number 169 dead is not going to help

Get Access