preview

Role Of Penelope In The Odyssey

Good Essays

In Homer’s Odyssey, we see a small side of Penelope as she greets her husband Odysseus after his return from his 20-year long journey; she is sweet and gentle, treating him as if he left for a day. In T.H.S. Wallace’s “So the Old Beggar with Bow Can Shoot Straight as Death” and Dorothy Parker’s “Penelope”, Penelope is transformed from a gentle woman into a harsher one. In The Odyssey, Penelope is described as a somber lady that misses her husband dearly. In the poems, however, she is depicted in a different light. The Penelope of T.H.S. Wallace’s and Dorothy Parker’s poems is different from Homer’s Penelope; she is harsh, vengeful, strong, and overall more complex. Primarily, it would be helpful to recount Homer’s portrayal of Penelope in …show more content…

In “Penelope”, she is bitter towards her husband, claiming that all the hard work that she did at home will be forgotten when Odysseus returns. In the poems, she describes Odysseus’ journey as relaxed. Odysseus’ journey is not easy nor relaxed, in fact, it was dangerous and much more difficult than it seemed to be. The last line of Parker’s “Penelope” has Penelope saying, “They will call him brave” which makes her sound resentful toward Odysseus for getting all of the recognition for doing “hard work”. Compared to The Odyssey, Penelope within the poem, “So the Old Beggar with Bow Can Shoot Straight as Death”, it seems like she does not trust him as much as she did within Homer’s Odyssey. Within the poem, Penelope assumes the commotion she hears within her home is Odysseus’ return, yet rather than being happy, she is simply just ready to face him for being unfaithful to her. In The Odyssey, Penelope does not assume that it is Odysseus, nor does she know of his infidelity. As soon as she realizes the man she sees is Odysseus, she runs into his arms, crying tears of happiness and joy. In both poems, we see Penelope as envious and vengeful. She is envious that no one will see her as brave for putting up against the suitors and doing hard, household work, and she is vengeful because her husband was unfaithful and gone for so long. Penelope is not envious, nor is she vengeful in The Odyssey. Penelope was happy that her husband has returned and knows that as he was returning home, his journey was that of a difficult one. As a result, the Penelope within both poems is not a good representation of the Penelope within Homer’s Odyssey because it emphasizes her bad qualities: harshness, vengeance, envy, and

Get Access