Of the more than 11,000 women transported as convict labor to the Atlantic colonies, all but a small fraction were impoverished. Within the metropole, these poor women were viewed as a burden on society, often dependent upon parish rolls and private charity, when available, for a subsistence living. While the general public was broadly sympathetic to the plight of widows and sometimes single mothers, such sympathy disappeared when women engaged in criminal activity. It is this link between poverty and crime that will be explored in this chapter, with a particular focus on the ways in which women engaged in criminal activities. This chapter takes a thematic approach over a long period of time when society changed little for poor and …show more content…
Such activity by the familiar worked to support a common fear: that crime would be committed by the socially inferior employee against the socially superior employer, fueling public concern. The majority of women who were tried and sentenced to transportation, however, did not appear to have been engaged in regular employment and apparently relied on theft-related crimes for a subsistence living.
A Solution for Poor and Idle Women
In some, this enterprise will minister matter for all sorts and states of men to work upon; namely, all several kinds of artisans, husbandmen, seamen, merchants, soldiers, captains…; yea old folks, lame persons, women, and young children, by many means which shall still be ministered unto them, shall be kept from idleness, and be made able by their own honest and easy labor to find themselves, without surcharging [via charity] others.
—Richard Hakluyt, A Discourse on Western Planting
Hakluyt’s Discourse on Western Planting, Written in the Year 1584 is one of the first works to reveal an unease that may have been broadly felt within England: that if the English did not expand in the Americas, then Spain and Portugal would continue to expand their empires to the exclusion of Britain. The fear was that England would not “be able to thoroughly to knowe the riches and comodities of
White convict women and young orphan girls were seen by many (both men and women) as breeding stock for settlers. Male colonists needed women as wives, mothers, sexual partners, and domestic servants. Often convict women were viewed as depraved unattractive incourageable whores (Summers, 1975), (Dixon,1999). Those cast out were often sent to houses of correction termed “Female Factories”. The factories also acted as female hiring depots where the
Economic status is a relevant aspect in the experience of punishment. To an individual who sternly believes that the American justice system entitles every person to the same standard of due process, the previously mentioned idea is blasphemous. Unfortunately, the concept is false. The American justice system does not equally accommodate the needs of criminals placed on trial. Class is relevant in the experience of punishment only because economic inequality is barely recognized in the formulation and carrying out of prison sentences. The foundation of this unjust punishment is laid down at the trial, where disadvantaged individuals find themselves the victims of stereotypes, poor legal representation and haphazard verdicts. Once imprisoned, lower class criminals become immersed in an environment which mimics the troubled circumstances that originally led them to commit crime. Having received an ineffective sentence, convicts return to their poor communities and are expected to reintegrate into society without proper treatment.
7) In criminological theories, we saw how police activity is largely geared towards minor visible crimes committed by individuals from the lower stratums of society as oppose to “white collar crimes” committed by those of higher stratums (Dubé, CRM 3701, 2011). Abolitionists argue that by severely punishing some of the poor in order to deter society from committing crimes; we are only further contributing to the inequalities in today’s society.
The female convicts exported to Australia have been the subjects of investigation since transportation commenced. Many historians set out to determine whether the female convicts were “vicious criminals” or “innocent victims”. Garton’s article researches the debate concerning the origins and characteristics of the convicts being
The events of this period of english settlement are best understood within the context of expansionism. As land in the “New World” was being discovered, the zeal for
By what percent has the U.S. prison population increased in the last three decades? The U.S. prison population has increased 790%.
There have been many changes in the treatment of offenders by the Criminal Justice System in England and Wales, particularly the treatment of female offenders. The handling of women within the criminal justice system has been closely tied to their social characteristics, and to what might be described as their ‘social construction’. On the other hand, women who compromise more than half of the world’s population, account for only 15% of criminal activity and as a consequence, relatively little attention has been given to them. This essay will explore how this has changed from a historical point of view to modern times, with exploration from cross-culture comparisons and an overview of the treatments of females in prisons.
In England, many colonists are caught, “...often pilfering and thieving and other lewdness...” (Document 1D4) Due to the lack of jobs, there are numerous homes with no source of income. Without income, it becomes impossible to obtain food and resources needed in order to survive. This leads to drastic measures from the people in despair. In order to survive, many people have to resort to crime regardless of the consequences.
The convict indent of the Pyramus (Making Australian History, Perspectives on the Past Since 1788, pp. 97-101) helps to distinguish trends arising with the convicts and their sentences. The Pyramus displays information on 30 convict women who all received a seven-year sentence, except for two who both attained life sentences, albeit similar crimes were committed. This trend highlights why historians might perceive convicts as victims of an unjust legal system, as a woman who had been convicted of quite a minor offence was given the same sentence as one convicted of a severer crime. The majority of women listed in this particular indent were detained for the violation of stealing, which poses the question, were that many women all serious criminals or were they indeed just “good people who lived in difficult times”? Case studies have been completed on several convicts and are an exceptional way of discovering the real personality and traits of individual convicts.
Social class and crime and punishment has always been an issue in the UK if not globally. For the elite, the criminal justice system serves a purpose to deter and prevent crime, but the reality is that the poor are punished for crimes they commit more so than those of a upper class who commit the same crime. The question is who is to blame for this image of the poor being criminals and the working class crime phenomenon, is it the moral Panic created by the media to distract from the reality of the white collar corporate crime being carried out by the most powerful of society or is it down to Poverty, Labelling, economic and social positioning which all contribute to deviant behaviour. The aim of this essay is to provide a critical criminological view of the punishment of the poor with a wide range of theories and ideas to contribute to the understanding of the poor being punished from the 18th century to today 's contemporary society. It will aim to develop an understanding how criminals and deviant behaviour were defined and perceived from historical periods to now.
or the same criminal behavior, the poor are more likely to be arrested; if arrested, they are more likely to be charged; if charged, more likely to be convicted; if convicted, more likely to be sentenced to prison; and if sentenced, more likely to be given longer prison terms than members of the middle and upper classes.1 In other words, the image of the criminal population one sees in our nation’s jails and prisons is distorted by the shape of the criminal justice system itself. It is the face of evil reflected in a carnival mirror, but it is no laughing matter.
Crime in this country is an everyday thing. Some people believe that crime is unnecessary. That people do it out of ignorance and that it really can be prevented. Honestly, since we live in a country where there is poverty, people living in the streets, or with people barely getting by, there will always be crime. Whether the crime is robbing food, money, or even hurting the people you love, your family. You will soon read about how being a criminal starts or even stops, where it begins, with whom it begins with and why crime seems to be the only way out sometimes for the poor.
A violent crime occurs every 23.5 seconds in the United States of America. Even though crime has been at a low during the past decade, violence is still prevalent in today’s society. Most of these crimes happen in places that are socio-economically disadvantaged. There then is the debate of whether violent crime is associated with environments struck with poverty. There is a correlation between violent crimes and poverty because of the unemployment rates in major cities, the culture of poor areas, and drugs.
This paper will be a critical analysis of the book, “Women Behind Bars: The Crisis of Women in the U.S. Prison System. This paper will
Poverty and the relationship it has to crime is a long standing sociological, humanists and historical phenomenon. From the plight of the third world to the violence soaked inner city streets of the 1980’s, the relationship of crime and poverty has been the source of a great deal of social commentary. In societies throughout the world and throughout history there has always been a traditional measure of deviance through relative income gaps. Both poverty and crime as well as their connections are heavily weighed topics of political and social discourse. Opinions in these areas contain a great deal of variance. The prejudices of the old guard from the professional police era still utilize association with poverty as a measuring stick for social deviance. Meanwhile, intelligent social science continues to give insight to factors such as social disorganization, socialization into violence, as well as, the far reaching impact political, economic and justice based policies have on those in poverty.