preview

The Black Cat Vs Tell Tale Heart Essay

Decent Essays

There are cases of films detering from their original written counterparts. However if the original author would be appreciative of the film is often a mystery. In the film adaptation of “The Tell Tale Heart,” directed by Steve Carver, and originally written by Edgar Allen Poe, the mystery is more so because Poe had been dead for over a century by the time that this adaptation of his story was made. Poe would have been appreciative of the film adaption of his story The Tell Tale Heart directed by Steve Carver because it seamlessly integrates his story The Black Cat into this storyline, it adds depth by changing the relationship between the butler and the old man, and lastly adding a detective element into the plot. One reason that Poe would be appreciative of the film adaption of his short story the Tell Tale Heart is because of its attempts …show more content…

The black cat was another of Poe’s works but while the tell tale heart focuses more so on the ramifications and effects of violence, the short story the black cat turns its attention more so on the violence itself. Although Poe’s work of the tell tale heart is not thematically of violence it still contains the act of murder. In the short film produced by Steve Carver the cat, that is not there in the original version of the story, plays a major role. This is justified by the fact that the cat is seen right before the climax of the film and in other events where any thoughts or actions associated to violence takes place. These examples show some connection between the two stories. In the black cat, the more the man hates the cat, the more the cat likes him, until this situation drives the man to insanity (as well as some other factors) and the man ends up attempting to kill the cat. This poses a parallel to the

Get Access