Athens had a democracy, and is known as being the “birthplace” of democracy. Five thousand men would be narrowed down to 500, then divided into groups of 50, who would take turns being in charge. Generals and these groups could propose laws and assess voting (Knights). However, only about 10% of the population had voting rights, pure Athenian men over 18, excluding women, slaves and the foreign born. Anyone who was present on the day of voting could raise their hands and vote and the decision made that day was final. They could also vote to eliminate anyone they felt was becoming too powerful which protected them against tyrants, but also limited their freedom of speech for fear of being exiled. Athenian government was also only open to those of the highest standing for the same reason as Sparta (Cartwright, Athenian Democracy). …show more content…
At age seven, boys left home and lived in military barracks where they were taught physical skills, discipline, how to handle pain, and survival skills. They were given small rations of food and were encouraged to steal in order to survive. At 20, boys were full time soldiers and served until age 60, and because they spent so much time around each other, homosexuality was a common occurrence. Soldiers were allowed to marry but could not live with their wives until they turned 30, and at that time were considered “equals”; these “equals” were given full rights and allowed to participate in politics (Sparta.net). While the conditions in our military are not nearly as extreme as they were in Sparta we have definitely adapted the concept of extreme discipline and survival skills to fit our own individual needs for our country. On the contrary, Athenian boys were only trained in the military for two years, from 18-20 (Ancient
There will always be conflicting viewpoints between the citizens of whom are governed by the same people regardless of the type of government being discussed. There are many contrasting views on Athenian democracy; however, some of the strength’s and weaknesses present in Athenian democracy hold similarities to the democracy we are today. “Our constitution does not copy the laws of neighboring states; we are rather a pattern to others than imitators ourselves,” (68). Pericles (ca. 495-429 B.C.E.) was a famous Athenian figure and political leader who wrote the speech called, “Pericles’ Funeral Oration,” to honor the fallen soldiers. A large piece of his speech was used to praise the Athenian democratic constitution.
One of the strengths of the Athenian democracy was that the people (males)had a voice for their city. If there was a problem or concern they were able to bring it up and discuss it among others. The men were not able to vote for everything, this was great because it didn’t allow one person to rule with power. The laws were created within the power of the people and then were passed according to the votes that the “people” casted.
Was ancient Athens truly democratic? Some may say yes and some may say no. But the answer is yes. The reasons are these. “ Fear is our chief protection against this, teaching us to obey the magistrates and the laws.” (Doc. A) This was one of the many statements Thucydides gave during his speech for Pericles’s funeral. The quoted statement essentially meant that during Thucydides time (460 – 395 BCE) there were laws and government rules that had to be followed. Men, women, and even slaves obeyed the laws and government rules because they thought they made sense and had no other reason to disobey. In that case, they wouldn’t have the need to be angry at their neighbors if they were too loud. This document written by Aristotle is a great example
Democracy, the form of government in which there is a rule by the people, is said to have originated and thrived in the classical period of Athens, from 500-350 B.C.. Democracy inherently gave all that were considered citizens power to participate in politics. That being said, it is highly debated as to how much power the people, also known as the demos, exercised in this democracy. Many practices and informal institutions can be said to have limited the power of the demos. The democracy in Athens could be said to have been a democracy in theory yet not in practice, as can be proven through a variety of primary sources recounting Athenian political institutions and practices. Such primary sources that can demonstrate this include Herodotus’ History, Thucydides History of the Peloponnesian War, and Demosthenes’ Oration Against Eubulides.
In the past week I have read different documents about the Ancient Athens and whether or not it was a true democracy. To sum up all the documents my hypothesis was true. I believed they weren't a true democracy. Athens wasn’t a true Democracy because Demokratia was ruled by male citizens only which made up 12% of the population. Women, slaves, and foreigners weren't allowed to vote.
Democracy is defined as the the rule by the people which Athens did not show in their government. The Athenian Democracy was ruled by The Ekklesia, The Boule, and The Dikasteria. The Ekklesia, Boule, and Dikasteria were made of the assemblies, council of 500, and courts, which does not include all the people of Athens. Demokratia exemplifies that all the people have the right to power/rule the government.
Athens was Democraticless Democracy can be defined as the power of the people. For example, America is a democracy. Athens claimed to be a democracy. Based on recorded speeches and the Athenian Constitution they did not favor the people. In some ways they did, but there is credible evidence showing Athens was not a democracy. There are statistics, facts, and examples. For instance, in a speech by Aristotle, he states, the citizens had to vote a new citizen. Voting is unjust based on citizens unfair judgments. If the potential citizen is declined citizenship, he must have a trail. If the citizen loses, he is then sold as an Athenian slave. Both of those laws do not favor the people. It is very easy for current citizens to mistreat the system.
Despite having a Limited Democracy, Athens enjoyed many freedoms. An example of these freedoms would be people voting, the Athenians could vote. Athens had a democracy with a very high citizen participation. Athens had a democracy where there was large amounts of participation in it. An example of this would be the Vase in Document 1, it shows multiple Athenian people that are working together on a project.
Democracy. A democracy is a government which all the people of the state are involved in making decisions, such as voting for representatives. So was there a democracy that was set by the Athens? Or was it an oligarchy that represents how everyone is supposed to live. Although many say the athens lived a democratic life, the evidence says it itself, they didn’t.
their high standards and they were not going to change it. Athenian was most criticized for being
There are multiple reasons why ancient Athens was not a Democracy in its truest sense. In Document A of the Athenian constitution, it clearly states.. “ Our constitution favors the many instead of the few,’’ however, if that were accurate, why could only twelve percent of the population vote (Document C).The Philosopher, Plato, concluded that women should have the same education and hold all positions in society (Guided Reading Activity 1-2 question 10); this is the very same conundrum that the American government had to face back in the 1920’s (Amendment 19), and it still has not been completely addressed to this day. If the Athenian constitution had favored the many as it claimed than 100 percent of the population should been allowed to vote.
Ancient Athens prided itself upon being a democratic society, but was it really? It's true that it was ruled by the people, however only a small percentage of people. Document C states that only 12 percent of people actually vote. And who are those 12 percent? The 12 percent of the whole population that voted was men whose parents were both citizens of the city (see Document B). Slaves, women, and resident foreigners were barred from voting.
People may say Athens was not a democracy because of the fact that only 12% of the population could vote. Although, if you look at the definition of democracy, it says, “all the eligible members of state.” In Athens, the eligible members of state were any citizens that were men. It may also be argued that because they had slaves,
Democracy has been a huge focal point for success especially in the west with countries like America, but sometimes we can see a democracy turn corrupt. This essay will be centered around the pros and cons of democracy and its roles within the ancient Greek world that helped catapult Athens into one of the world’s greatest metropolitan cities to ever exist.
The democracy in Athens mattered remarkably to it’s citizens and had great power and control after the Persian Wars. During this time, Athens focused solely on strengthening their democracy and spreading their ideas to other city-states. Socrates grew up during this time of prosperity in Athens. When Socrates was a young boy Athens was seen as a highly successful with a large amount of power. Socrates grew up to become a philosopher and devoted his life to finding “The Good” meaning he had a much different view overall about gods and higher powers than other Athenian philosophers of his time.