preview

The Major Contributions Of Dissenting Minority Religions And The Collective Efforts Of Non Elite Followers

Good Essays

Focusing on the major contributions of dissenting minority religions and the collective efforts of non-elite followers, Buckley breaks with the trend of ignoring the vast majority of Virginia colonists on subjects not named the Great Awakening. However, his work slips into the realm of presentism with a strong hint of bias when he discusses the uneasy alliance between colonial rationalists and evangelicals in their fight for disestablishment. Buckley argues that although they agreed on many issues, they disagreed on the relationship of church and state. While rationalists believed in a total separation, “the intent of the evangelicals was not a complete separation of church and state in rationalist terms nor the privatization of religion.” His underlying argument is clear; the United States owes its freedom of religion not to the ‘Founding Fathers’ but to the populace of Virginia, many of whom associated themselves with a ‘dissenting’ religion who believed in the freedom of voluntary association and the continuation of some form a church/state relationship. Buckley, the Jesuit priest writing in the 1970s, was supporting an argument for increased church activity in the public sphere by arguing that the legal and academic fields had misrepresented the intentions of colonial Americans by emphasizing too much on the intent of Revolutionary leaders. Certainly, the intent of all church historians writing during the period was not to advocate an increased religious presence in

Get Access